On Sep 30, 2008, at 10:23 AM, Kristof Zelechovski wrote:

I am not against INPUT[type=search]; I am against INPUT[results=10] because
I cannot see how it can be reasonably preset.

Yeah, that's weird. I think if I designed it myself, I would have made the presence of autosave (instead of results) trigger the magnifying glass icon, used a sensible default for the number of items in the search history (maybe 10 or 20), used something like historylength to override it, and make setting historylength=0 disable the menu (leaving the icon). Something like that. But that's not how Apple did it, and we should be compatible with them.

Is this control for simple search only or is it designed to be used in an
advanced search interface?  Should it be unique within a form?

Excellent question! I imagine it should be unique within a form. Whether it's appropriate for an advanced search interface would depend on the interface; if there's one input that's an obvious choice for type="search" then go ahead and use it, otherwise it might be better to stick with type="text".

Hopefully someone more qualified than I can provide a better answer.

--
Andy Lyttle
[EMAIL PROTECTED]



Reply via email to