There is a piece by Wes on the website of the Knight Foundation[1] and an
additional FAQ on Discovery's "Knowledge Engine" development on

The Knight Foundation funds many things, and is a past donor to the
Wikimedia Foundation--but I'm aware that the Knight Foundation is also
Google's partner in "Newsgeist".[3][4]


On Wed, Jan 6, 2016 at 3:17 PM, MZMcBride <> wrote:

> Wes Moran wrote:
> >The Discovery team has begun six months of research and prototyping, with
> >the goal of building better experiences to help people discover knowledge.
> >You can learn more about the team’s work here
> ><
> >.
> This blog post doesn't mention the Knight Foundation. So we already find
> ourselves wondering whether the "Search and Discovery" (SAD) team's goals
> are its own or that of people at the Knight Foundation.
> >Our deliverables include:
> >
> >   - User testing and research on current user flows to understand the
> >   search and discovery experience
> >   - Creation and maintenance of a dashboard of core metrics to use in
> >   product development
> >   - Research on search relevancy and the possibility of integrating open
> >   data sources
> >   - Open discussion with the Wikimedia community of volunteer editors
> >   - Creation of sample prototypes to showcase discovery possibilities
> >
> >The need to improve our search experience has long been recognized across
> >the Wikimedia projects.  We need better ways to help everyone discover the
> >most relevant, reliable information on Wikipedia and its sister projects.
> >For example, while people can search within one project (like Wikipedia or
> >Wikimedia Commons), they can’t easily search across the different
> >projects.
> Yes. My frustration here is that nothing you're proposing will actually
> address the real problems facing search. Do you think a "dashboard of core
> metrics" is going to bring about inter-wiki search? If anything, over the
> next six to eight months, the SAD team will be even more useless than
> usual as it focuses on fulfilling obligations of a restricted grant.
> It would be great to have a search engine that searches all wiki pages on
> a local wiki. We haven't even reached that point yet. It would be great to
> have a search engine that is aware of non-text content and can filter
> media results. We're nowhere near that point yet. But in a few months,
> maybe your team will have a better understanding of "user flows" and that
> will help... something. I certainly won't be holding my breath.
> MZMcBride
> _______________________________________________
> Wikimedia-l mailing list, guidelines at:
> New messages to:
> Unsubscribe:,
> <>
Wikimedia-l mailing list, guidelines at:
New messages to:

Reply via email to