On 06/09/2004, at 9:43 PM, Dylan Egan wrote:
Hi,
If you have no worries about shunting out a massive percentage of IE (and other browser) users to adopt a new technology with very little support, then go for it.
Yes, that's sarcasm.
It's more about what should we be limiting ourselves too. I know most people use IE out there, but should that really stop us? If we sit back and wait and wait, I dont think anything will come of it.
You should be limiting yourself to tricks & tools which are widely accepted by your audience, or degrade gracefully so that your audience can still access the content/functionality regardless.
AFAIK, XForms does not fit in this category at all, and *I* wouldn't use it on anything less that a corporate intranet with guaranteed support by all clients.
Im not so much going to be forcing people who are visiting these sites to use the ideal browser, but if they want an enjoyable experience they would need to use that browser.
You need to clearly define "enjoyable". If you mean "it works", then I think you're headed down the path of inaccessibility. If you mean "works faster/easier/smarter", then sure!
I just want to get an idea of how many people are inserting hacks into their code to satisfy the older browser department and what are they going to do when a new technology comes around that one browser will never support, but is still the major browser throughout the net.
I generally don't hack for backwards compatibility in the mark-up at all. I do a little CSS hacking, but it's limited to the bare minimum required, and they're clearly defined and separated into their own file for easy recognition and later removal. But you're not talking about hacks on HTML or CSS for backwards compatibility, you're talking about using a technologies which the browser HAS NO CLUE ABOUT. Not good I say.
As for new technologies, it's going to be really tough -- we're *getting there* with support for CSS2, XHTML, etc, but pretty soon browser manufacturers will be far down the path on CSS3, XHTML2 and many other newer technologies, and we'll be looking at an uphill battle once again as we wait for browsers to catch up.
Personally, I wouldn't use XForms anywhere that wasn't a 100% controlled environment.
--- Justin French http://indent.com.au
****************************************************** The discussion list for http://webstandardsgroup.org/
Proud presenters of Web Essentials 04 http://we04.com/ Web standards, accessibility, inspiration, knowledge To be held in Sydney, September 30 and October 1, 2004
See http://webstandardsgroup.org/mail/guidelines.cfm for some hints on posting to the list & getting help ******************************************************
