On 9/27/2010 8:53 PM, Khaled Hosny wrote:
You know, because Windows has the most consistent user interface an OS
ever had.
(From some one who is yet to see two "native" Windows applications that
behave the same)
Yeah, yeah, look, my name isn't "Gates", but in windows the idea is,
and virtually every applicaiton sticks to this, "if there's multiple
windows, you get them INSIDE a master frame". I'm not going to argue
that every single app developer went "yes windows design style guide, I
will unquestioningly do what you say" but the vast majority of important
applications obeys this simple unwritten rule.
I never said TeXWork was a bad program - it's great. But i annoys the
hell out of me that it launches two applications when it says it's one.
You close the right application, the left application doesn't close.
Wtf? I thought I was running one program? So it's two applications...
you close the left applicaiton, the right one does close. Again, wtf? So
it IS one program? This is not good design for a windows application. It
doesn't matter that some other people write good programs with bad UIs
on windows, too. A worthwhile program uses the visual semantics that
come with the OS it's made for. Stick both the windows side by side in a
master frame when the code detects it's being compiled for Windows, make
them visible and invisible via checkboxes in view/window->source and
view/window->final or something, and presto, the entire gripe's gone.
Now it's a cross platform editor that respects the user expectation of
the vast majority of people who are going to be new to TeX.
Some people love TeXWork because it's a better alternative to everything
they tried before, but that's because *they've tried everything else and
didn't like it*. It's almost impossible to miss that means you're hardly
new at TeX, but that you're a long time user who's sampled everything
there is to sample over an extensive period of time and settled on
TeXWorks because it lets you get the job done. That's great, if TeXWorks
is where you ended up, awesome, it's a really good program, even on
windows. It also breaks the idea of a single application that people
that are new to TeX, and use windows, will be used to. When you're new
to something, you don't want a program that behaves completely different
from all the other big programs you use. You want to give someone new to
TeX a familiar base first, so they don't tune out going "this is so
radically different that I cannot get comfortable with it". Then, once
you're familiar enough with it to realise that even a plain text editor
on a command prompt works just fine (even if it's more work), looking at
better editors that take away the UI familiarity is no longer
objectionable. It's basically common sense. Familiarity + a little bit
of new, then shift focus until the new is familiar, then drop the
original hook you needed to convince people it was worth getting
familiar with the new.
- Mike "Pomax" Kamermans
nihongoresources.com
--------------------------------------------------
Subscriptions, Archive, and List information, etc.:
http://tug.org/mailman/listinfo/xetex
