At 06:15 PM 10/03/2007, you wrote:
>If you made a mistake typing and address, you probably want to know about
>it, don't you?
>
>
>- Davide

Actually I'd like the option to prevent Xmail from returning all errors, 
especially 'user does not exist' ones (even if it's not an RFC thing).

If its one of my local uses sending mail to an invalid address, I have no 
problem with them knowing about it via a 'warning email'.
However, if it's someone external trying to send mail to an invalid user on 
one of our local domains, (especially if that email comes in via one of our 
secondary mail servers) I would much rather simply drop the connection, and 
return nothing at all.

Numerous times we've had people spoof a return address and then send a 
stack of dictionary-attack-spam, to our domains (often arriving via the 
secondary servers, which are never used by our legitimate users to send 
external email).
Since most uses do not exist, our server then bounces back a significant 
number of NDR's.
If the spoofed return address is real, the person who owns the email 
account often thinks that we are spamming them (all the "error messages" 
returned by Xmail).
This has gone far enough to get us blacklisted on some of the more radical 
lists, and our hosting provider to charge us for "spam-investigation 
incidents" - when it's been nothing but Xmail bouncing back (large numbers 
of) "cannot be delivered" error emails.
If the sending address does not exist, stacks of NDR messages fill up 
Xmail's spool because they can't be delivered.

So while I understand the reason for returning non-deliverable messages, it 
would be very helpful if Xmail at least had an option to turn off of ALL 
error returning.
If this setting existed it would be very useful to use on our secondary 
mail servers.

Regards,
Scott

-
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe xmail" in
the body of a message to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For general help: send the line "help" in the body of a message to
[EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to