Thanks, Cde Castro for re-posting this "open letter" from Zwelinzima Vavi on earth to Chris Hani in heaven, now that a decent interval has passed since Cde Vavi's "open letter" was first released to the national print and electronic media at fourteen minutes before 10h00 on the 10th of April 2012.
It gives us an opportunity to ask a couple of questions about what happened with this "open letter". And since you have made it your business to promote the "open letter" all over again, Cde Castro, then maybe you are in a position to provide some answers to such questions? I hope you will do so. By the way, I was not at Chris Hani's graveside on the 10th and I do not have any special knowledge of what I am asking about, other than the public e-mails that I have received, now including yours. Below this message, I have pasted an extract from the SACP's media alert of the previous evening. That is, precisely 19h36 on the 9th of April. This was a repeat of the notice which had been sent out to the media four days earlier. As you can see from what is pasted below, at twenty-four minutes to eight p.m. on the evening before the solemn graveside event, in honour of the anniversary of the SACP's previous-but-one General Secretary, who was assassinated while in office as General Secretary of the SACP, the SACP was still confidently and publicly announcing that Cde Vavi, as General Secretary of COSATU, was going to speak at the graveside along side of the present SACP General Secretary and representatives of many other organisations. Instead of doing so, Cde Vavi sent his Deputy, Cde Bheki Ntshalintshali to speak at the graveside. Then, fourteen minutes before the event as scheduled to start, Vavi released his 2500-word "open letter" to Chris Hani, to 2300 e-mail addresses of the national (bourgeois) mass media of communications. It is not for me to say what Cde Vavi's intentions were, but I can say that I know Cde Vavi to be highly conscious of the impact, and of the timing, of such media releases, just as much as you are, Cde Castro. The effect of Vavi's action was that many of the media led their reports with Vavis' fantasy letter to the dead Hani in heaven, where he makes all the claims to personal support from Cde Chris that comrades will have read, over the top of the dignified event that the SACP had organised in conjunction with the Hani family at the graveside. At the very least, Cde Vavi's behaviour looks like extremely bad manners. At the worst it looks like rank hostility to the SACP and to everything that the late Hani actually stood for. In other words, it looks like hypocrisy on Cde Vavi's part, and demagogy, for that matter. That's what it looks like. As to Cde Vavi's subjective intentions, we do not yet know, but what we would find hard to believe is that these acts and the timing of these acts would have been a mistake, or some sort of coincidence. Cde Vavi's acts are rightly presumed to be deliberate, and not blunders. So, the first question to you, Cde Castro, about this "open letter" that you have made it your business to re-send, 18 days later, is what was Cde Vavi's intention in standing up his engagement with the SACP and the Hani family and "going it alone" with his theatrical Letter to Hani in Heaven? While you are doing so, you may as well state your own intentions in this matter, Cde Castro. Thank you. VC. Here is the SACP Press Alert of 9 April 2012 19:36 The following commemorative activities will take place on the 10th April 2012: *Activity : Wreath laying ceremony* *Time : 10H00* *Venue : Thomas Nkobi Memorial Park* *Speakers: SACP General Secretary, Cde Blade Nzimande* * COSATU General Secretary, Cde Zwelinzima Vavi* * Ekurhuleni Executive Mayor, Cde Mondli Gungubele* * YCL SA National Secretary, Cde Buti Manamela* * ANC, COSATU and SANCO leaders* * * On 28 April 2012 07:05, Castro Ngobese <[email protected]> wrote: > Zwelinzima Vavi’s letter to Chris Hani on the 19th Anniversary of his Death > Tshonyane! > Didiza! > Chungwa! > Sawa! > Nkomo! > Mthunzi uzimele! > Simke! > Hani! > Mgqunukhwebe! > General Secretary of our vanguard party - SACP > Chief of staff of our glorious army - umkhonto wesizwe > Leading member of our people's movement - ANC > > It was on this day 19 years ago, that you were brutally gunned down > outside your home in Dawn Park. > > Your death continues to strike a very sensitive chord amongst the working > people of this country, who saw in you their liberator and a general who > was committed to leading them to their own version of a land of milk and > honey. > Your death marked an immeasurable loss sustained not only by the poor in > this unequal land called South Africa, but to many others across the world, > who came to appreciate your role and immense contribution in one of the > most dramatic events of the 20th century – the fall of apartheid. > > It was on this day that you took your last leap and met your untimely > death at the hands of those who hated peace and enjoyed an enduring affair > with counter-revolution and anti-communism. > > One of the deepest scars on the visage of our democracy is the reality > that a soldier like you, who toiled and laboured to ensure that the > people’s thirst for equality and justice is quenched, had his life brutally > taken away at such a defining moment of our struggle against apartheid and > capitalism. > > Although your assassination sent shockwaves across the world and paralysed > many of those who saw in you a true representative of mass power, we have > come to appreciate that as a revolutionary who fully understood the deep > hatred possessed by those who have an immortal hatred for communism and its > principles of equality and justice, you had made peace with the fact that > there are only two results in a revolution: death or victory. > > Your life continues to inspire new generations of South Africans, a > glittering example of a courageous revolutionary leader of his people, > personifying the noblest principles and finest traditions of our liberation > and socialist movement - selflessness as against self centeredness, > collective leadership as against personality cult, solidarity as against > survival of the fittest, sacrifice for common good as against greed and > individualism. > > All of us, particularly those of us who speak in the name of the working > class, are duty bound to learn from what you taught us so well and strive > to emulate your record of service to the people. > > You departed at perhaps one of the most difficult moments of our struggle > against apartheid when the enemy camp in the form of the apartheid regime > and all its supporters was waging an onslaught on our people and making > several disastrous changes to the economy. > > The widespread privatization, which has robbed many poor people of their > hard-won citizenship rights in a democratic South Africa – was a trend the > white minority regime initiated in its last days. > > At the same time, the regime also launched a massive offensive against our > people and made use of force and death squads, in collaboration with the > IFP, to force our people into surrender and submission. > > The Boipatong massacre, whose 20th anniversary we will be commemorating in > June this year, is one of the most painful chapters in our history where > our people were stabbed, maimed and butchered by the enemy camp as part of > its dirty tricks. > > We remain convinced that your assassination was part of this greater plot > to cajole our people and its movement into capitulation. Your brutal > assassination led to the death of your father in our struggle O.R. Tambo > who could not stomach the images of your body and blood on television. Your > own biological parents soon departed. No parent would like to see his own > offspring in a pool of blood on national television. > > Tshonyane, we are certain that you will find comfort in the knowledge that > the working class in this country is still a fighting class, forever > engaged in a battle to reclaim the means of production and ultimately free > humanity from the burdens of capitalism. > > The working class in South Africa today remains as militant as it was when > you departed from the land of the living. > > A simple glance at the COSATU organised march against labour brokers and > e-tolling would tell you that the working class remains as radical as it > was when if fought the apartheid’s regime’s introduction of a Value Added > Tax (VAT) on basic foodstuffs, healthcare and essential services. > > We speak without fear of contradiction when we say that the massive show > of strength by the people against labour brokers and the privatisation of > the roads was a clear referendum against the stranglehold that capitalists > have over our country and our economy. > > It was a clear message and reminder to the government of the Freedom > Charter principle that no government shall assert its authority on the > people without their consent. > > I am certain that you were watching with pride and envy as thousands of > the poor rallied behind COSATU’s call for the banning of labour brokers and > the cancellation of the e-tolling system. > > We have no doubt that were you alive today, you would have formed part of > the picket line calling for the banning of labour brokers and an end to the > privatisation of our roads. > > There is no doubt in our hearts that you would be impressed by the strides > that the ANC has made in the transformation of the lives of many South > Africans. We have one of the world`s most democratic constitutions, a bill > of rights, and a constitutional court which checks that the laws and courts > comply with that Constitution. > > Over 2.5 million houses have been built for the poor, giving shelter to > over ten million people. 6 million households have gained access to clean > water since 1994 and electricity has been connected to nearly 5 million > homes. In 1994, only 62% of households had access to clean drinking water - > today 93% do. > Today 77% of the households have access to decent sanitation and 84% have > access to electricity. By 2010, 14.5 million people were receiving social > grants. Tshonyane you would be very impressed by this progress registered > in 17 short years. > > Despite these great achievements however, some the struggle remains an > uphill climb and only the working class is capable of leading us out of the > web. > As we commemorate the 19th anniversary of your assassination, the > capitalist class across the world continues to mount unprecedented attacks > on the living standards of the working class and the poor. > > Tshonyane, many of us, the working poor, are still super exploited and > continue to labour for a pittance in the factories and the farms that give > our bosses millions and millions in profits. > > Approximately 35% of adult men and women are rendered idle by > unemployment. Most worrying is that 72% of these are young people between > 15-36 years of age and 60% have less than secondary education. > There remains a stark racial element to unemployment. A 2002 study found > that despite similar qualifications, whites are on average 30% more likely > to be employed than Africans. > > It is this high unemployment that condemns many of us to a life of > indignity. This unemployment has turned many healthy workers into beggars, > who have to knock on relatives’ doors for their next meal. > > The struggle for jobs is still intricately linked to the challenge to > build a more equitable and just society. South Africa’s wage gap is one of > the highest in the world, and is still growing. > > Shoprite CEO Whitey Basson in 2010 took home the highest-ever monthly > earnings ever recorded in a single year – an unbelievable R627.53 million > in salary, perks and share options. All this whilst workers in the same > company earn between a minimum of R1800 and R4000 depending on whether you > are labour broker employed or so called permanent worker! > The brazen exploitation of the masses of the people by the mine owners, > the land barons and farmers as well as the greedy retail giants in this > country remind us of the reasons why we find it so hard to forget you. > > From the mines of Rustenburg and Kimberley to the clothing factories of > Durban and Cape Town, the militant working class remembers and misses you > dearly. > > Just like unemployment, inequality is also racialised. While black South > Africans` salaries increased by 38% between 1995 and 2008, the incomes of > white South Africans rose by 83.5%! > > The warning you issued just a few years before your death that failure to > properly address the HIV and AIDS would “result in untold damage and > suffering by the end of the century” was precise. > Your children, those for whom you crossed borders and lay your head in > distant lands, continue to die of HIV and AIDS. > > Although government has managed to make antiretroviral treatment available > to over a million people, the rate of infection is still far too high. > > We know that you would be furious to learn that while South Africa has > less than 1% of the world’s population, it still has 17% of people living > with HIV/Aids, the highest incidence in the world. And that life expectancy > rates are falling and now stand at 56 for women and 51 for men. The death > rate has doubled in nine years! > > We remain convinced that if that bullet did not end your life so early and > in such crucial time South Africa would have not lost 10 years to HIV and > AIDS denialism during which 350 000 people died including many leading > cadres of your movement. > > These grim statistics are part of the broader battle between the two main > contending classes in South Africa and indeed the world. It is a battle > that we intend to win! > > The legacy of apartheid is seen by simply looking at the festering sore of > underdevelopment and poverty that plagues the former Bantustans. The poor > education system that children in townships and rural areas are subjected > to is a constant reminder of the damage that apartheid inflicted on the > working class. > > I had an opportunity to drive frequently in the former Transkei Bantustan > recently. Whilst it is clear that strides have been made to improve the > lives of our people there is no doubt that it still resembles a labour > reserve area that the apartheid regime designed. > > We know that you would have greatly disapproved of the spate of careerism > plaguing the movement today. > > This we know because throughout the years that you served the movement, > modesty is one of the character traits you are revered for. > > When many were angling for the corridors of power in a new democratic > South Africa, you, the people’s commissar, chose instead to continue in > service of the working class as the General Secretary of the party of > socialism – the South African Communist Party. > > Responding to some who expressed shock at this decision you courageously > retorted: > “The perks of a new government are not really appealing to me. Everybody > would like to have a good job, a good salary…..but for me that is not the > be-all of struggle. What is important is the continuation of the struggle… > the real problems of the country are not whether one is in Cabinet …but > what we do for social upliftment of the working masses of our country.” > > If only there were more cadres like you today! If only the revolution > could continue to produce cadres defined by selflessness as opposed to > egocentrism and the desire to serve the people as opposed to using the > movement as a step ladder to their careers! > > In these trying times when the people’s movement is at war with itself – > where labelling and innuendos, careerism and opportunism, patronage, > selective justice, cherry-picking on corruption and the criminalisation of > dissent, leaks and character assassinations, pigeonholing and casting > aspersions are all at their peak – we remember that you too were once > subjected to unspeakable treatment from those who could not withstand the > truth contained in what we today call the Hani memorandum. > > As a fierce democrat in your own right, we are certain that rather than > throwing foul-smelling labels at fellow comrades merely because they share > different views about the tempo and direction of our struggle, you would > instead encourage widespread debate and discussion. > > We know this because history teaches us that Hani the commander was an > ardent believer in the notion of the battle of ideas and like many > communists of similar calibre, believed that a healthy political > environment requires that “a hundred flowers bloom and a hundred schools of > thought contend”. > > We know through your own example that you would have encouraged young > people to continue to be militant and be intolerant of their today's > economic circumstances of unemployment and a faltering education system > that marginalises millions, labour brokering, etc. you would have insisted > on discipline and respect for older comrades. > > We know you would not have allowed the type of ill-discipline we saw and > chose to conveniently ignore because it was directed at others we disagreed > with. That standing on a chair and shouting down older comrades would have > not happened of you were around. You would have been amongst those who > insisted at the ANC NGC the ill-discipline must end. > > You would be in the forefront of efforts to renew our movement and > challenge the new cultures that threaten the very existence of our glorious > movement. We know you would mobilize the masses of the people to battle > against the self enrichment programmes currently underway. > > You would have been in the opposite of the new class if tenderpreneurs. > You would have confronted blossoming factionalism that is tearing our > movement apart. > > You would have condemned mediocrity these factions impose on our people > and we know you would have decried the roll-overs that rob the poor the > services they are yearning for. > > You would not have tolerated those failing to spend infrastructure budgets > just because they are in a faction you support. > > The struggle against social injustice, poverty and deprivation can only be > won through mass mobilisation and a united front, dedicated to putting an > end to the capitalist honeymoon that we have been experiencing since 1994. > > You were the most ardent spokesperson of the poor and the most > unapologetic commander of the oppressed, who defined his destiny as > synonymous with the destiny of the working class of this country. > > For this reason, you were simultaneously the best friend of the working > class and enemy number one of the capitalist class which continues to steal > the wealth created by those who till the soil with the sickle in the farms > and operate the grinding machines in the factories. > > Your deeds and principles will forever inspire us to advance the struggle > against capitalism, and imperialism to the highest levels. > > Commander, teacher, comrade, leader, revolutionary and martyr, the working > class in this beautiful country wishes to assure you that we will continue > to train new soldiers who are willing and able to give battle to the twin > enemies of the people – capitalism and its higher stage which is > imperialism. > > We miss you Tshonyane > > Comradely yours > > Zwelinzima Vavi > > > Sent from my iPad > > > -- You are subscribed. This footer can help you. Please POST your comments to [email protected] or reply to this message. You can visit the group WEB SITE at http://groups.google.com/group/yclsa-eom-forum for different delivery options, pages, files and membership. To UNSUBSCRIBE, please email [email protected] . You don't have to put anything in the "Subject:" field. You don't have to put anything in the message part. All you have to do is to send an e-mail to this address (repeat): [email protected] .
