-Caveat Lector-
http://www.best.com/~dolphin/yeshua.html
IT'S TIME FOR ISRAELIS TO LEARN JESUS WAS JEWISH
[Excerpts from HA'ARETZ newspaper, Thursday, 23 December 1999]
-------------------------------------------------------------------
Israeli pupils hear about Jesus only once during 12 years of
schooling, so they know nothing about Christianity, and don't have
a key to understanding the history and culture of the western
world. The education system prefers ignorance to being suspected of
missionary activity.
Ninth-graders at a high school in Bat Yam were asked last Friday, a
week before Christmas, what they knew about Jesus. According to the
high school history teacher who dared ask the question, most knew
nothing - not even the most basic details: when he was born, where
he lived and preached, when he died and how.
They did not know that he was a believing Jew, who was born,
according to historians in the year 4 BCE (and not in the year 0),
in Bethlehem, and that his mother's name was Miriam, that is, the
Virgin Mary.
Some thought that Mary Magdalene, the prostitute, was the mother of
Jesus. They did not know of the decision by the Sanhedrin to turn
him in on the grounds that he pretended to be "the king of the
Jews," or of his trial before the Roman governor, Pilate. As for
the Sermon on the Mount, the values he preached, the dispute
between him and the Pharisees and the Sadducees over the
interpretation of the law and the concept of the Messiah, and the
connection between Jesus and the Essene sect - the students knew
nothing.
History lecturers believe that this ignorance is not a negligible
matter. Israeli students who do not know anything at all about the
figure of Jesus are unable to understand the faith of the
approximately two billion Christians in the world and they have no
key to the understanding of the history, music, painting, sculpture
and architecture of the western world. Moreover, they lack basic
knowledge of the history of Judaism and society in the land of
Israel 2000 years ago.
This ignorance comes as no surprise. According to the official
curriculum, students in the government education system hear about
Jesus at best only once during 12 years of schooling - and only in
passing, at the beginning of their sixth grade history course, in a
brief chapter on "Jesus and the First Christians" in the history
text "During the Days of Greece and Rome."
According to Michael Yaron, the supervisor of history instruction
at the Education Ministry, Jesus is not studied again in high
school, because in high school the curriculum concentrates mainly
on the 19th and 20th centuries, and not everyone is even required
to study the chapter in the sixth grade, as elementary schools have
the autonomy to pick and choose in the curriculum.
In the government-religious system, students learn even less: in
the seventh grade textbook "From generation to generation" there is
a brief and laconic treatment of Jesus in the chapter "Sects in
Judaism." Sarah Weider, the supervisor of history instruction in
the government-religious educational system, notes that religious
teachers teach about Jesus with great reservations - for example,
they do not mention his name explicitly. The reason: "Because it is
impossible to ignore what Christianity did to the Jews, and
attribute to the man what was done in his footsteps, even if he was
not to blame."
According to history teachers, even on class outings from
government schools to Jerusalem and the Galilee, Christian holy
sites are totally ignored. Weider says about religious school
trips, "They don't go into Catholic churches, because there is a
halacha that prohibits this, but they do look at them from the
outside."
Now and then, some teachers, like the history teacher in Bat Yam,
find it important to deviate from the regular program of studies
and teach their students something about the traditions and beliefs
of others. But they, according to their own testimony, are an
infinitesimal minority.
History lecturers at the universities in Israel say that high
school graduates arrive at university "totally ignorant" about
everything concerning Jesus and Christianity. "They know nothing at
all," says Dr. Aviad Kleinberg of Tel Aviv University, the author
of the book "Christianity from its Beginnings to the Reformation,"
a ministry of defense publication for the University of the
Airwaves.
"I encounter a great deal of rejection, hostility and ignorance
with respect to Jesus and Christianity in general. They live two
meters away from places that many Christians in the world only
dream of visiting, and they know nothing about them."
According to Kleinberg, this is the result of "neglect and
conservatism in the educational system, which must be changed. The
Israeli educational system must be less concentrated within itself
and more open to the study of the other. It would not hurt children
if they read a chapter from the New Testament and the Koran. This
is not only important morally, but also for their Jewish identity:
they should know what is similar and what is different. It is
important for Israeli students to know something about Jesus, and
that they should read at least something about the Sermon on the
Mount."
In his classic text, "The Jewish Sources of Christianity,"
Professor David Flusser wrote a great deal about the importance of
the Sermon on the Mount to the understanding of the Jewish
traditions of Jesus's time.
"In the Sermon on the Mount, Jesus interprets the words of the
Torah with moral strictness," he wrote. For example, Jesus preached
(in Hebrew and Aramaic): "Blessed are the poor in spirit: for
theirs is the kingdom of heaven. Blessed are those who mourn: for
they shall be comforted. Blessed are the meek: for they shall
inherit the earth- Blessed are the peacemakers: for they shall be
called the children of God" (Matthew 5:3-5,9).
In this, according to Flusser, Jesus represented a strain of
thought in Jewish thinking at a time when it was necessary to pay
more attention to morality and love of one's fellow men, and he
placed less value on external rituals.
Jesus also expressed a view contrary to the Judaism and established
Christianity of our day, that views success and wealth as evidence
that an individual has observed the commandments, and failure or
poverty as punishment for sins.
According to Jesus, it is precisely the rich who need to examine
themselves: "For it is easier for a camel to go through a needle's
eye, than for a rich man to enter the kingdom of heaven" (Luke
18:25). That is, in order to be saved, a person must give up his
assets in this world, and thus, blessed are the poor.
Israeli students who study this could perhaps perceive the beliefs
that prevail today and lie at the basis of western capitalism in a
more critical light.
Professor Michael Harsegor, who has discussed Jesus in recent weeks
on his program "History Hour" on army radio, says: "Jesus was the
most famous Jew in the world, and students must know why he was
famous and why he was a Jew."
Harsegor says that students should know that "the greatest
invention of Paul, the man who spread Christianity, was to give up
two things in the Jewish tradition that frightened the gentiles of
the time: the dietary restrictions of kashrut, and circumcision.
Yet, adds Harsegor, "Jesus said several times that nothing in the
Law (Torah) must be changed," and "Jesus was a double figure. On
the one hand he was soft and very passive ) 'Whosoever shall smite
thee on thy right cheek, turn to him the other also" (Matthew 5:39)
- and on the other, a dictator: believers were exhorted to love him
more than members of their own family."
According to Harsegor, students should also know that all of his
"evangelists and disciples came from the Galilee, and were
considered in snobbish Jerusalem to be primitive, and therefore,
when Jesus came to Jerusalem, they scorned him. Only Judah
Iscariot, who betrayed Jesus, came from Judea, from the more
intellectual sect."
He says that students in Israel should also learn the parable of
the good Samaritan: a Cohen and a Levite pass by a man who lay
dying by the side of the road after thieves attacked him, and they
do not come to his aid.
"But a certain Samaritan, as he journeyed, came where he was: and
when he saw him he had compassion on him, and went to him, and
bound up his wounds, pouring in oil and wine, and set him on his
own breast, and brought him to an inn, and took care of him"
(Luke 10:33-34).
The lesson is clear, says Harsegor: "It is wrong to cling to the
Torah, like Cohen and the Levite, and do nothing more. You have to
be humane, like the Samaritan, who is not a religious Jew."
Harsegor regrets that "Israeli students see the cathedrals of
Europe and don't know anything. They are ignorant because the
schools are still afraid that any study of Jesus is connected to
missionary activity."
Professor Guy G. Stroumza, chairman of the Center for Study of
Christianity at the Hebrew University in Jerusalem, says that
"Jesus was a good Jew. There were a few things that the rabbinical
establishment at the time didn't like, but he wasn't an especially
great revolutionary either.
"However, he was a uniquely interesting and important figure in
western culture, a key figure in the land of Israel in the 1st
century, at a time of political ferment. Students in Israel have a
huge gap in their education. Altogether, the interest in religions
is a new thing in the Israeli academy, perhaps because Zionism
arose as an anti-religious movement. There is no doubt that it is
necessary to study the New Testament.
Dr. Ninmrod Aloni, who teaches an advanced seminar on humanist
education at Seminar Hakibbutzim, says that he tries to teach Jesus
as an example of the way, "the figure of a wonderful individual,
the main point of whose teaching was love and charity and pity and
solidarity and all the beautiful things, was exploited by the
religious establishment - the Christian church, the Crusades and
the Inquisition, which up until the 17th century burned people in
his name.
"I talk about the Jesus I know mainly from three sources - the New
Testament, A.A. Kabak's 'In the Strait Path' and 'Gospel According
to Jesus Christ' by Jose Saramago - in order to explain to people
how religion can be opium for the masses, how it can make people
forget its origins and encourage its exact opposite."
Dr. Eyal Naveh, whose book on the history of the 20th century
aroused debate recently, believes there "apparently was a decision
in the educational system not to go deeply into the study of
Christianity, but this does not mean that students know anything
about Judaism, even though there is a decision to go deeply into
the study of Judaism.
"For students to remember anything of what they have learned
depends on the way they are taught. If they teach them something
that is relevant to the contents of their own world, if the
learning is an experience, they will remember.
"My children learned about Jesus at the Democratic School in Kfar
Sava in the context of art, and now they know a fair amount about
Christianity and Jesus as a prophet or false prophet. If it is
decided that this is relevant to the children's world, and they
teach them in an interesting way, there is no reason why they
should not remember."
"Ignoring Jesus is part of the tendency to concentrate only on
ourselves, as if we had sprung up outside a universal context. In
the case of Jesus, this is especially absurd, because Jesus is
linked to our development. I hope that things will change, and that
the system will realize that history is not just a collection of
facts, but is about substantial issues that shape our world. The
connection between Judaism and Christianity is definitely one of
the issues that shapes our world."
This year, says Weider, "out of sensitivity to the year 2000, we
held a continuing education program this summer for teachers, and
the relation between Judaism and Christianity was one of the
subjects. We realized that this year educators have to be sensitive
to this issue."
Dr. Nili Keren of Seminar Hakibbutzim says that students from the
college are going on field trips this year to the Judean desert,
around the Dead Sea, in the footsteps of John the Baptist. But
Michael Yaron, the education ministry's chief supervisor for the
teaching of history says that nothing will change: there is no
possibility for expanding and going more deeply into the study of
Jesus in Israeli schools, because in any case there are not enough
study hours," and, he adds, "considering the number of hours we do
have to teach our students, I would not eliminate other subjects in
order to add this subject.
posted December 28, 1999.
-------------------------------------------------------------------
Back to Lambert Dolphin's Library:
http://www.best.com/~dolphin/asstbib.shtml
.
DECLARATION & DISCLAIMER
==========
CTRL is a discussion and informational exchange list. Proselyzting propagandic
screeds are not allowed. Substance—not soapboxing! These are sordid matters
and 'conspiracy theory', with its many half-truths, misdirections and outright
frauds is used politically by different groups with major and minor effects
spread throughout the spectrum of time and thought. That being said, CTRL
gives no endorsement to the validity of posts, and always suggests to readers;
be wary of what you read. CTRL gives no credeence to Holocaust denial and
nazi's need not apply.
Let us please be civil and as always, Caveat Lector.
========================================================================
Archives Available at:
http://home.ease.lsoft.com/archives/CTRL.html
http:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/
========================================================================
To subscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email:
SUBSCRIBE CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED]
To UNsubscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email:
SIGNOFF CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Om
