We are voting on the release artefact itself, primarily. The correctness of the code is a secondary concern. We have, and will continue to, ship code with bugs in it. But we cannot ship code when the packaging is incorrect. That is why I am happy to vote +1 on an artefact that has been packaged correctly, under the assumption that other folk will flag any flaws with the software.
I have experienced segmentation faults and bus errors before with CouchDB, and it is a known issue. Because of this, I didn't believe it was an issue. Not sure what use pasting the logs will provide, as they simply stop with the message that there has been a segmentation error. It happens when CouchDB is starting up again after a crash. A manual restart works. And doing so while the test suite ran resulted in passing tests. If this alarms anyone, I can do it again, and collect specific information for you. (I don't know what to say about 1.1.2 working with R15 and SpiderMonkey 1.8.5. Thems the version numbers I have, and I was able to compile and run the code.) On 2 January 2013 18:12, Robert Newson <rnew...@apache.org> wrote: > And neither 1.0.4 nor 1.1.2 should work with erlang R15 or spidermonkey > 1.8.5. > > I'm fine that some folks can't test properly due to lack of access to > old dependencies but that also means you can't take part in the > testing and voting for those artifacts. It's inappropriate to vote for > an artifact you haven't tested. > > B. > > On 2 January 2013 18:06, Randall Leeds <randall.le...@gmail.com> wrote: > > On Wed, Jan 2, 2013 at 9:59 AM, Noah Slater <nsla...@apache.org> wrote: > > > >> Running all tests with Erlang R15B02 (erts-5.9.2) and SpiderMonkey > 1.8.5. > >> > >> = 1.0.4 = > >> > >> Got as far as: > >> > >> ./configure --prefix=/tmp/couchdb/install > >> > >> This is from the Checking the Release Artefacts section in the release > >> procedure. Unable to configure the source because my SpiderMonkey is too > >> new. Tried to compile from source, but got errors. No available Ubuntu > >> image has a package old enough. I am happy that the release is fine, > >> though, obviously, I have been unable to run the code or run either test > >> suite. > >> > >> This artefact gets my +1 > >> > >> = 1.1.2 = > >> > >> Got as far as running the Futon test suite. (Surprised I got this far > with > >> my up-to-date versions of both Erlang and SpiderMonkey.) Extensive > >> segmentation faults and bus errors. All tests pass except oauth. > >> > >> This artefact gets my +1 > >> > >> = 1.2.1 = > >> > >> Completed the Futon test suite. Extensive segmentation faults and bus > >> errors. All tests pass. > >> > >> This artefact gets my +1 > >> > >> > >> > > This concerns me, Noah. It's expected on your configuration that 1.0.4 > > would not work, though I'm surprised you +1 anyway. On the others, 1.1.2 > > should work, though I have OAuth failures with newest Erlang, too, but > > 1.2.1 should work totally correctly and neither should have seg faults. > > > > Could you paste some log showing the seg faults and bus errors? > > > > > >> > >> On 29 December 2012 20:12, Dave Cottlehuber <d...@apache.org> wrote: > >> > >> > Hello, > >> > > >> > We would like to call a vote for Apache CouchDB, 1.0.4, 1.1.2, and > 1.2.1, > >> > first round, maintenance releases, to start your New Year with a bang. > >> > > >> > We encourage the whole community to download and test these release > >> > artifacts so that any critical issues can be resolved before the > releases > >> > are made. Everyone is free to vote on this release, so get stuck in! > >> > > >> > We are voting on the following release artifacts, by different release > >> > managers to spread the load. > >> > > >> > Robert Newson: > >> > http://people.apache.org/~rnewson/dist/1.0.4 > >> > > >> > Dave Cottlehuber: > >> > http://people.apache.org/~dch/dist/1.1.2 > >> > http://people.apache.org/~dch/dist/1.2.1 > >> > > >> > PGP Keys: > >> > https://people.apache.org/~dch/dist/KEYS > >> > > >> > These artifacts have been built from the following git commits: > >> > > >> > 1.0.4: 514b7ef95cf67a06f094d56b6ab86b4a770292bd > >> > 1.1.2: 306a6eb4405de878313b46ef026a6089503b693a > >> > 1.2.1: 5ebfa8e4bce7322ae0d7b7d95f269425cdb9a46c > >> > > >> > Please follow the test procedure before voting: > >> > > >> > http://wiki.apache.org/couchdb/Test_procedure > >> > > >> > Note the following restrictions for both 1.0.4 and 1.1.2: > >> > > >> > Erlang/OTP R14B* or lower > >> > Spidermonkey 1.8.0rc1 or lower > >> > > >> > Thank you. > >> > > >> > Happy voting, > >> > Dave & Bob. > >> > > >> > > >> > >> > >> -- > >> NS > >> > -- NS
