I suspect your network connectivity is too good :-)

Here is an experiment I tried:
Connected from Home with a Mobile Internet Connectivity of 230Kbps ( :-(
that's the best Home connectivity I can get in my place) and tried
downloading Geronimo Eclipse Plug-in by clicking on "Don't see your server
listed" link. After about 25mins and 7.1MB of download volume Plug-in
installation failed with a Network Connection Error. When I tried again
(thank God, download restarted from where it last failed) it took another
25mins for an additional download volume of 7.8 MB with 3 restarts!

After this I tried downloading a zip of eclipse plug-in (
http://people.apache.org/dist/geronimo/eclipse/unstable/g-eclipse-plugin-2.0.0-v20070430.1413-deployable.zip)
using a download accelerator. This time it took 50mins for 17MB of download
volume to complete and there were no download errors.

In addition being able to download a zip allows me to backup a copy of the
setup for later use, which wouldn't be trivial if I use automatic download
by IDE.

We probably can recommend users to install via Eclipse update site, yet make
available a zip of eclipse plug-in for direct download. What do you say?

We probably can also work to reduce the size of Geronimo Eclipse Plug-in.

- Shiva

On 5/10/07, Lin Sun <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:


Just one comment here...  When I last tried to download the geronimo
eclipse plugin, it was not slow at all.  I don't really see much
difference of using the eclipse update manager vs. go to the site to
download the zip file.   I think the preferred way is to use the eclipse
update site as it can install/update the feature and its dependencies
automatically on the fly.

Lin

Shiva Kumar H R wrote:

> A few observations I made as a User of Geronimo Eclipse Plug-in:
> 1) Downloading Geronimo Eclipse Plugin from within the IDE (by clicking
> on the "Don't see your server listed?" or by creating a new remote site
> in the update manager) is too slow.
>
> It would save a lot of time if I can simply download a zip of Geronimo
> Eclipse Plug-in say from
> http://geronimo.apache.org/development-tools.html (similar to the way I
> can download zips of most Eclipse Plug-ins from eclipse.org
> <http://eclipse.org>).
>

Reply via email to