> > I think the mp3 encoding library should do what it is > > supposed to do, encode pcm samples into mp3 frames. > > > > What the client software will add - ID3v2, WAV header, Xing header - > > that should be of no interest for the *encoding library*. > > However, the information in the Xing frame is dependant on information in > the total mp3 output. Now the encoding library could provide this info > easily. Why should the client have to calculate this again? Yes, that is the point. Rescaning the mp3 file and make vbr tag is a stupid idea. and, VBR tag is so popular and maybe a lot of frontend want to write it. Such a common needed function should be a part of library, I think. --- Takehiro TOMINAGA -- MP3 ENCODER mailing list ( http://geek.rcc.se/mp3encoder/ )
- [MP3 ENCODER] modularization Takehiro Tominaga
- Re: [MP3 ENCODER] modularization Mark Taylor
- Re: [MP3 ENCODER] modularization Takehiro Tominaga
- Re: [MP3 ENCODER] modularization Robert Hegemann
- Re: [MP3 ENCODER] modularization Mark Taylor
- Re: [MP3 ENCODER] modularization Mark Taylor
- Re: [MP3 ENCODER] modularization Robert Hegemann
- Re: [MP3 ENCODER] modularization Mark Powell
- Re: [MP3 ENCODER] modularizati... Robert Hegemann
- Re: [MP3 ENCODER] modulari... Takehiro Tominaga
- [MP3 ENCODER] mpglib related r... Takehiro TOMINAGA
- [MP3 ENCODER] mpglib related routi... Takehiro Tominaga
- Re: [MP3 ENCODER] mpglib relat... Mark Taylor
- Re: [MP3 ENCODER] mpglib r... Robert Hegemann
- Re: [MP3 ENCODER] mpglib r... Mark Taylor
- Re: [MP3 ENCODER] mpglib r... Frank Klemm
- [MP3 ENCODER] Fix for Make... Mark Powell
- Re: [MP3 ENCODER] mpglib r... Mark Taylor
- Re: [MP3 ENCODER] mpglib r... Takehiro Tominaga
- Re: [MP3 ENCODER] mpglib r... Frank Klemm
- [MP3 ENCODER] wrong protot... Frank Klemm