Re: [josm-dev] WMS and remote-control

2010-08-14 Thread Sebastian Klein

Komяpa wrote:

2010/8/12 Sebastian Klein basti...@googlemail.com:

Komяpa wrote:



1) Due to Landsat WMS being down and overloaded usually, we've set up
a caching WMS proxy for it.
JOSM URL is http://irs.gis-lab.info/?layers=landsat;
Please consider updating JOSM defaults.

Do you want it to show up in the list on the bottom, or make it installed by
default instead of the standard landsat URL?
Are you sure, you can handle the traffic?

This server also provides IRS imagery for Russia for quite a long time.
I'm sure it will be able to handle traffic. So, worth trying
installing it by default.


Done.


Now, we need a convenient way to load that imagery into josm. An
extenstion to josm-remote that will load specified WMS URL will be
just fine. Hope somebody will write it, as I'm no java coder,
unfortunately.

There are some security issues when the browser has too much control over
the client software.


As far as I know, josm-remote has options that lets paranoid users
disable some of its features if they dislike that.


OK, the question is: Make it opt-in or opt-out? Let's wait till it's 
ready, then we can decide...


Sebastian



___
josm-dev mailing list
josm-dev@openstreetmap.org
http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/josm-dev


Re: [josm-dev] WMS requiring an EULA acceptance

2010-08-14 Thread MP
 Again, the idea is not to build up a fortress. It is well known that if
  someone really want to catch the images, he will be able to do so anyway.
  The request to show and accept the uela is coming from the jurists, I cannot
  change that. What I would like to know is if it is possible and how I could
  do it in JOSM/WMS plugin without disturbing the main stream.

Solution requiring no modification of JOSM or WMS plugin could be that
the URL will require some parameter, like
http://wms-server?SERVICE=WMSREQUEST=GetMapeula_check=something

Value for that parameter will not be included in presets and for that
JOSM to work, user will have to browse to the site with EULA, agree to
the EULA and after that the site will tell him what to put in place of
the parameter, like eula_check=p45gG0h5w
(or perhaps it can tell him entire WMS URL, includnig the parameter)

Requests without correct value of eula_check parameter will be denied
on the WMS server side ans since the only way to get the parameter
will be by reading and accepting EULA - problem solved. Perhaps also
add clause to disallow telling value of the parameter to other people
if it is already not in the EULA. Then it should be completely safe
(from lawyers point of view)

Martin

___
josm-dev mailing list
josm-dev@openstreetmap.org
http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/josm-dev