My guide to birds of Europe says Redwing breeds in Scotland and winters in the
rest of Britain. I'm sure it's a fun bird to see, but it would not make
headlines. Their red is on the sides and wing lining. The Redwing shows actual
white on the brow and chin. Female Red-winged Blackbirds are
The original article correctly identifies the bird in question as a
Red-winged Blackbird and includes several diagnostic photos from Scottish
birders. I'm not sure why there's been any "confusion".
-Scott
On Tue, May 2, 2017 at 10:49 AM, Bill Mcaneny wrote:
> To clarify (or
To clarify (or to add to the confusion), there is a migratory thrush in
Europe that goes by the name of REDWING. It is not clear to me that the
bird in the report from Scotland is a Redwinged BLACKBIRD. The REDWING
looks superficially like the female blackbird, being brown, sort of stripey,
and
I wanted you to know that I got the forwarded note from a Scots woman colleague
whom I just showed a male Red-winged Blackbird to a couple weeks ago on a trip
around the pond, presumably for her first time.
I hope the Scots who get to add the F to their life list are as thrilled as I
was with