Re: [CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update

2020-08-03 Thread Jyrki Tikka
On 2020-08-03 18:43, Gordon Messmer wrote: On 8/3/20 2:21 AM, Jyrki Tikka wrote: The boot disks must have an EFI boot partition even though it's not used in this case. IIRC, they need a partition at the beginning of the drive to reserve space for GRUB2.  That should be a "BIOS boot

Re: [CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update

2020-08-03 Thread Gordon Messmer
On 8/3/20 2:21 AM, Jyrki Tikka wrote: The boot disks must have an EFI boot partition even though it's not used in this case. IIRC, they need a partition at the beginning of the drive to reserve space for GRUB2.  That should be a "BIOS boot partition" not an "EFI System partition" for

Re: [CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update

2020-08-03 Thread Jyrki Tikka
On 2020-08-03 05:56, John Pierce wrote: Legacy BIOS has its own set of issues, like no GPT support, MBR disks are max 2TB. I'm booting just fine on an old BIOS system from a pair (mdraid 1) of 3 TB GPT disks. The MBR compatibility on GPT disks allow the old machine to boot from a GPT disk

Re: [CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update

2020-08-02 Thread John Pierce
On Sun, Aug 2, 2020 at 7:14 PM Chris Adams wrote: > Once upon a time, Jonathan Billings said: > > On Aug 2, 2020, at 14:43, Pete Biggs wrote: > > > You don't have to use UEFI secure booting - most machines can fall back > > > to legacy booting using BIOS settings. If you do that, you won't use

Re: [CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update

2020-08-02 Thread Chris Adams
Once upon a time, Jonathan Billings said: > On Aug 2, 2020, at 14:43, Pete Biggs wrote: > > You don't have to use UEFI secure booting - most machines can fall back > > to legacy booting using BIOS settings. If you do that, you won't use > > any Microsoft signed code. > > Back in 2017, Intel

Re: [CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update

2020-08-02 Thread Gordon Messmer
On 8/2/20 4:11 PM, John Pierce wrote: isn't it more that they simply won't work with newer boots that were signed by the new keys? and the updated BIOS's won't boot older OS versions that weren't signed by the new keys? I don't know if the Secure Boot PKI has a publicly documented

Re: [CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update

2020-08-02 Thread Leon Fauster via CentOS
Am 02.08.20 um 04:15 schrieb Kay Schenk: Questions re this statement in the ZDNET article -- "In all cases, users reported that downgrading systems to a previous release to reverse the BootHole patches usually fixed their problems." A previous release of what? GRUB2 So that's my first

Re: [CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update

2020-08-02 Thread Jonathan Billings
On Aug 2, 2020, at 14:43, Pete Biggs wrote: > You don't have to use UEFI secure booting - most machines can fall back > to legacy booting using BIOS settings. If you do that, you won't use > any Microsoft signed code. Back in 2017, Intel said that it was going to deprecate the “Legacy” CSM by

Re: [CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update

2020-08-02 Thread John Pierce
On Sun, Aug 2, 2020 at 3:54 PM Gordon Messmer wrote: > On 8/2/20 1:19 PM, John Pierce wrote: > > One of the things that bugs me about PKI trust chains like this, what > > happens if the unthinkable happens, and Microsoft's RootCA gets > compromised > > and has to be revoked... does that mean

Re: [CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update

2020-08-02 Thread Gordon Messmer
On 8/2/20 1:19 PM, John Pierce wrote: One of the things that bugs me about PKI trust chains like this, what happens if the unthinkable happens, and Microsoft's RootCA gets compromised and has to be revoked... does that mean every single piece of UEFI hardware out there needs a BIOS upgrade?

Re: [CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update

2020-08-02 Thread John Pierce
On Sun, Aug 2, 2020 at 1:01 PM Phil Perry wrote: > I believe Microsoft signs the shim which then becomes the trusted > authority and embeds RH (or CentOS) signing cert, so (I believe) every > release of the shim needs to be signed by Microsoft. So it's not quite > as efficient as MS signing a

Re: [CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update

2020-08-02 Thread Phil Perry
On 02/08/2020 19:54, John Pierce wrote: On Sun, Aug 2, 2020 at 11:45 AM Phil Perry wrote: On 02/08/2020 16:26, Valeri Galtsev wrote: On the side note: it is Microsoft that signs one of Linux packages now. We seem to have made one more step away from “our” computers being _our computers_.

Re: [CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update

2020-08-02 Thread John Pierce
On Sun, Aug 2, 2020 at 11:45 AM Phil Perry wrote: > On 02/08/2020 16:26, Valeri Galtsev wrote: > > > > On the side note: it is Microsoft that signs one of Linux packages now. > We seem to have made one more step away from “our” computers being _our > computers_. Am I wrong? > > > > Valeri > > >

Re: [CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update

2020-08-02 Thread Phil Perry
On 02/08/2020 16:26, Valeri Galtsev wrote: On the side note: it is Microsoft that signs one of Linux packages now. We seem to have made one more step away from “our” computers being _our computers_. Am I wrong? Valeri Microsoft are the Certificate Authority for SecureBoot and most

Re: [CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update

2020-08-02 Thread Pete Biggs
> On the side note: it is Microsoft that signs one of Linux packages > now. We seem to have made one more step away from “our” computers > being _our computers_. Am I wrong? > Secure booting using UEFI requires that the code is signed - that is the "secure" bit. Microsoft are the CA for that

Re: [CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update

2020-08-02 Thread Stephen John Smoogen
On Sun, 2 Aug 2020 at 13:35, Alessandro Baggi wrote: > > > Il 02/08/20 19:09, Alessandro Baggi ha scritto: > > > > Il 02/08/20 18:54, Stephen John Smoogen ha scritto: > >> On a side note, you keep emphasizing you aren't expecting an SLA.. but > >> all your questions are what someone asks to have

Re: [CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update

2020-08-02 Thread Alessandro Baggi
Il 02/08/20 19:22, Valeri Galtsev ha scritto: On 8/2/20 12:09 PM, Alessandro Baggi wrote: Il 02/08/20 18:54, Stephen John Smoogen ha scritto: On a side note, you keep emphasizing you aren't expecting an SLA.. but all your questions are what someone asks to have in a defined SLA. I have

Re: [CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update

2020-08-02 Thread Alessandro Baggi
Il 02/08/20 19:09, Alessandro Baggi ha scritto: Il 02/08/20 18:54, Stephen John Smoogen ha scritto: On a side note, you keep emphasizing you aren't expecting an SLA.. but all your questions are what someone asks to have in a defined SLA. I have done the same thing in the past when things

Re: [CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update

2020-08-02 Thread Valeri Galtsev
On 8/2/20 12:09 PM, Alessandro Baggi wrote: Il 02/08/20 18:54, Stephen John Smoogen ha scritto: On a side note, you keep emphasizing you aren't expecting an SLA.. but all your questions are what someone asks to have in a defined SLA. I have done the same thing in the past when things have

Re: [CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update

2020-08-02 Thread Alessandro Baggi
Il 02/08/20 18:54, Stephen John Smoogen ha scritto: On a side note, you keep emphasizing you aren't expecting an SLA.. but all your questions are what someone asks to have in a defined SLA. I have done the same thing in the past when things have gone badly, but couching it in 'I am not asking'

Re: [CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update

2020-08-02 Thread Stephen John Smoogen
On Sun, 2 Aug 2020 at 12:08, Alessandro Baggi wrote: > > Hi Johnny, > thank you for your answer. I always accepted release cycle of CentOS > without any problem (maybe with EL8 but it is ok). > > I don't need SLA and I don't blame anyone for this, errors can occour. For > example in this story, I

Re: [CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update

2020-08-02 Thread Alessandro Baggi
Hi Johnny, thank you for your answer. I always accepted release cycle of CentOS without any problem (maybe with EL8 but it is ok). I don't need SLA and I don't blame anyone for this, errors can occour. For example in this story, I applied blindly updates without check what and how so really I ran

Re: [CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update

2020-08-02 Thread Valeri Galtsev
> On Aug 2, 2020, at 9:14 AM, Gregory P. Ennis wrote: > > On 8/2/20 2:47 AM, Alessandro Baggi wrote: >> >> Il 02/08/20 00:42, Mike McCarthy, W1NR ha scritto: >>> It appears that it is affecting multiple distributions including Debian >>> and Ubuntu so it looks like the grub2 team messed up.

Re: [CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update

2020-08-02 Thread Marc Balmer via CentOS
> Is the latest update : > shim-x64 x86_64 15-7.el7_9 No. 15-8 is. ___ CentOS mailing list CentOS@centos.org https://lists.centos.org/mailman/listinfo/centos

Re: [CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update

2020-08-02 Thread Gregory P. Ennis
On 8/2/20 2:47 AM, Alessandro Baggi wrote: > > Il 02/08/20 00:42, Mike McCarthy, W1NR ha scritto: > > It appears that it is affecting multiple distributions including Debian > > and Ubuntu so it looks like the grub2 team messed up. See > > > >

Re: [CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update

2020-08-02 Thread Johnny Hughes
On 8/2/20 2:47 AM, Alessandro Baggi wrote: > > Il 02/08/20 00:42, Mike McCarthy, W1NR ha scritto: >> It appears that it is affecting multiple distributions including Debian >> and Ubuntu so it looks like the grub2 team messed up. See >> >>

Re: [CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update

2020-08-02 Thread Patrick Bégou
Le 02/08/2020 à 09:47, Alessandro Baggi a écrit : > > Il 02/08/20 00:42, Mike McCarthy, W1NR ha scritto: >> It appears that it is affecting multiple distributions including Debian >> and Ubuntu so it looks like the grub2 team messed up. See >> >>

Re: [CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update

2020-08-02 Thread Alessandro Baggi
Hi Paride, I also have a debian 10 on a workstation and some VMs for test purpose. Probably you updated after the grub-regression update but I noticed several stories about debian breakage. Il 02/08/20 01:13, paride desimone ha scritto: I use debian buster on my old notebook, an asus f3ja

Re: [CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update

2020-08-02 Thread Alessandro Baggi
Il 02/08/20 00:42, Mike McCarthy, W1NR ha scritto: It appears that it is affecting multiple distributions including Debian and Ubuntu so it looks like the grub2 team messed up. See https://www.zdnet.com/article/boothole-fixes-causing-boot-problems-across-multiple-linux-distros/ Mike On

Re: [CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update

2020-08-01 Thread Kay Schenk
Questions re this statement in the ZDNET article -- "In all cases, users reported that downgrading systems to a previous release to reverse the BootHole patches usually fixed their problems." A previous release of what? GRUB2 So that's my first question. Second. I'm assuming the the

Re: [CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update

2020-08-01 Thread Kay Schenk
My system was happy UNTIL I rebooted. ThenBZZT!!! On Sat, Aug 1, 2020, 17:02 Schatzi Olsen wrote: > And for whatever reason, both my centos 7 and 8 survived this apparently > with flying colors. Actually, this is out of character for how fate has > been dealing the cards recently. > >

Re: [CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update

2020-08-01 Thread Schatzi Olsen
And for whatever reason, both my centos 7 and 8 survived this apparently with flying colors. Actually, this is out of character for how fate has been dealing the cards recently. I'm very leary about rebooting either, now, though. On Sat, Aug 1, 2020 at 12:50 PM Kay Schenk wrote: > Totally

Re: [CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update

2020-08-01 Thread Kay Schenk
Mike -- Thanks for the clarification and more information. ___ Sent from MzK's phone. On Sat, Aug 1, 2020, 15:42 Mike McCarthy, W1NR wrote: > It appears that it is affecting multiple distributions including Debian > and Ubuntu so it looks like the grub2 team messed up. See

Re: [CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update

2020-08-01 Thread paride desimone
I use debian buster on my old notebook, an asus f3ja and I have not grub throuble. I try a virtual mschine with testing and unstable, and both boot regularly Il dom 2 ago 2020, 00:42 Mike McCarthy, W1NR ha scritto: > It appears that it is affecting multiple distributions including Debian > and

Re: [CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update

2020-08-01 Thread Kenneth Porter
Another ZDNet story on the issue: https://www.zdnet.com/article/red-hat-enterprise-linux-runs-into-boothole-patch-trouble/ ___ CentOS mailing list CentOS@centos.org https://lists.centos.org/mailman/listinfo/centos

Re: [CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update

2020-08-01 Thread Laack, Andrea P
who donate their time and energy to supporting the CentOS project. Andrea -Original Message- From: CentOS On Behalf Of Mike McCarthy, W1NR Sent: Saturday, August 1, 2020 5:42 PM To: centos@centos.org Subject: {EXTERNAL} Re: [CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update CAUTION:  

Re: [CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update

2020-08-01 Thread Mike McCarthy, W1NR
It appears that it is affecting multiple distributions including Debian and Ubuntu so it looks like the grub2 team messed up. See https://www.zdnet.com/article/boothole-fixes-causing-boot-problems-across-multiple-linux-distros/ Mike On 8/1/2020 6:11 PM, Marc Balmer via CentOS wrote: > > >> Am

Re: [CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update

2020-08-01 Thread Marc Balmer via CentOS
> Am 01.08.2020 um 23:52 schrieb Leon Fauster via CentOS : > > Am 01.08.20 um 23:41 schrieb Kay Schenk: >> Well misery loves company but still...just truly unfathomable! >> Time for a change. > > > I can only express my incomprehension for such statements! > > Stay and help. Instead running

Re: [CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update

2020-08-01 Thread Leon Fauster via CentOS
Am 01.08.20 um 23:41 schrieb Kay Schenk: Well misery loves company but still...just truly unfathomable! Time for a change. I can only express my incomprehension for such statements! Stay and help. Instead running away or should I say out of the frying pan and into the fire? :-) -- Leon

Re: [CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update

2020-08-01 Thread Kay Schenk
Well misery loves company but still...just truly unfathomable! Time for a change. ___ Sent from MzK's phone. On Sat, Aug 1, 2020, 13:04 david wrote: > At 12:50 PM 8/1/2020, Kay Schenk wrote: > >Totally and completely on my HP microfiber. Wouldn't get past anything to >

Re: [CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update

2020-08-01 Thread david
At 12:50 PM 8/1/2020, Kay Schenk wrote: Totally and completely on my HP microfiber. Wouldn't get past anything to even get me into the grub menu. NOT AMUSED! ___ Kay Schenk I was going to confirm the same, but the system that became unbootable was my mail system :-(

[CentOS] Boot failed on latest CentOS 7 update

2020-08-01 Thread Kay Schenk
Totally and completely on my HP microfiber. Wouldn't get past anything to even get me into the grub menu. NOT AMUSED! ___ Kay Schenk ___ CentOS mailing list CentOS@centos.org https://lists.centos.org/mailman/listinfo/centos