[computer-go] Analysis of 6x6 Go

2008-09-24 Thread Ingo Althöfer
Erik van der Werf wrote: ... Optimal play on 6x6 under Chinese rules is expected to give a Black win by 4 points. I want to lay open, why my expectation for 6x6-Go under Chinese rules is +2 for Black. With Leela, I played two games (or game fragments) in analysis mode, starting the machine

Re: [computer-go] Analysis of 6x6 Go

2008-09-24 Thread terry mcintyre
To satisfy my standards of proof, games would have to be post-analyzed to determine whether either side could have made better moves. Duplicate games would be thrown out; games with inferior play would be tossed. We might not have the resources to completely solve the game, but we could improve

Re: [computer-go] Analysis of 6x6 Go

2008-09-24 Thread Erik van der Werf
On Wed, Sep 24, 2008 at 6:30 PM, Don Dailey [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I don't know if even size boards are special, but it seems to me that such small boards should have very high komi's. 4.0 seems pretty low but then I'm really no expert on komi's and I'm a pretty weak player so I'm not in

[computer-go] MoGo v.s. Kim rematch (Jason House's paper)

2008-09-24 Thread Jacques Basaldúa
The approach of this paper is to treat all win rate estimations as independent estimators with additive white Gaussian noise. Have you tried if that works? (As Łukasz Lew wrote experimental setup would be useful) I guess there may be a flaw in your idea, but I am not a specialist. I will try

Re: [computer-go] Analysis of 6x6 Go

2008-09-24 Thread Don Dailey
On Wed, 2008-09-24 at 09:42 -0700, terry mcintyre wrote: To satisfy my standards of proof, games would have to be post-analyzed to determine whether either side could have made better moves. Duplicate games would be thrown out; games with inferior play would be tossed. We might not have the

RE: [computer-go] MoGo v.s. Kim rematch

2008-09-24 Thread David Fotland
This is an interesting idea, but do you have any actual results? If you implement this kind of rave formula do you get a stronger program? David -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:computer-go- [EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Jason House Sent: Wednesday, September 24,