Re: [computer-go] analysis of UCT and BAST

2007-11-21 Thread Markus Enzenberger
Remi Munos wrote: I have updated the BAST paper, providing additional comparison with UCT, as suggested by one person in the list. See: https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00150207 after reading the paper, I have two questions: How did you deal with unexplored nodes in Flat UCB and BAST in your

Re: [computer-go] analysis of UCT and BAST

2007-05-31 Thread Łukasz Lew
Please notice that it is not my work. All the experiments were performed by Filip Gruszczynski. He corrected the webpage. (should be EGO_POWER) Best Regards, Lukasz On 5/30/07, Rémi Coulom [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Łukasz Lew wrote: I'm not sure whether You have noticed, but my student made

Re: [computer-go] analysis of UCT and BAST

2007-05-31 Thread Łukasz Lew
On 5/31/07, Remi Munos [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Thanks Lukasz for the link. I'm not sure to understand precisely the formulas. For example, for ego_bast_sqrt, you mention that the bast value of a node is the min of the As I said previously this is not my experiment. You can reach the author -

[computer-go] analysis of UCT and BAST

2007-05-30 Thread Remi Munos
I have updated the BAST paper, providing additional comparison with UCT, as suggested by one person in the list. See: https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00150207 Basically, in the considered examples, BAST with an appropriate smoothness sequence performs always better than both UCT and Flat-UCB. Now,

Re: [computer-go] analysis of UCT and BAST

2007-05-30 Thread Łukasz Lew
I'm not sure whether You have noticed, but my student made an empirical comparison between BAST, UCT and other formulas. It can be found here: http://students.mimuw.edu.pl/~fg219435/Go/ Best Regards, Lukasz Lew On 5/30/07, Remi Munos [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I have updated the BAST paper,

Re: [computer-go] analysis of UCT and BAST

2007-05-30 Thread Rémi Coulom
Łukasz Lew wrote: I'm not sure whether You have noticed, but my student made an empirical comparison between BAST, UCT and other formulas. It can be found here: http://students.mimuw.edu.pl/~fg219435/Go/ Best Regards, Lukasz Lew Hi Łukasz, You write that EGO_BAST seems to be a bit more