Re: CMSP 09. Clarify intent of 'recommends' and add 'suggests'

2009-10-10 Thread Zefram
David Golden wrote: The 'recommends' flag is not equivalent to Debian recommends. The intent should be made clear for authors and the toolchain. If the Debian definitions are adopted to better match usage by packagers, a 'suggests' field should be added as well. (Adam Kennedy) There's too

Re: CMSP 09. Clarify intent of 'recommends' and add 'suggests'

2009-10-09 Thread Graham Barr
On Oct 9, 2009, at 6:46 AM, David Golden wrote: 09. Clarify intent of 'recommends' and add 'suggests' Proposal: The 'recommends' flag is not equivalent to Debian recommends. The intent should be made clear for authors and the toolchain. If the Debian definitions are adopted to better

Re: CMSP 09. Clarify intent of 'recommends' and add 'suggests'

2009-10-09 Thread Hans Dieter Pearcey
Excerpts from Graham Barr's message of Fri Oct 09 09:43:42 -0400 2009: one option could be though that the failure for a recommended dependency to install could still allow the dependent to install On one hand, maybe this would be useful for things that e.g. offer a mod_perl interface, and

Re: CMSP 09. Clarify intent of 'recommends' and add 'suggests'

2009-10-09 Thread David E. Wheeler
On Oct 9, 2009, at 4:46 AM, David Golden wrote: * 'recommends' or 'suggests' they both imply (to me) they list optional dependencies. Perhaps we could have both, where 'suggests' implies the toolchain should ask whether the user wishes to install listed dependencies, and 'recommends'

Re: CMSP 09. Clarify intent of 'recommends' and add 'suggests'

2009-10-09 Thread David Golden
On Fri, Oct 9, 2009 at 1:19 PM, David E. Wheeler da...@kineticode.com wrote: On Oct 9, 2009, at 4:46 AM, David Golden wrote: * 'recommends' or 'suggests' they both imply (to me) they list optional  dependencies. Perhaps we could have both, where 'suggests' implies the  toolchain should ask