Re: [ALL] DOAP file placement - move out of trunk?

2013-03-13 Thread Simone Tripodi
Hi, Seb But Onami does not appear in projects.apache.org! I could not find the Onami DOAP - where is it? each Onami's component website's page has a link / element which points to its related DOAP, i.e. * the main site http://onami.incubator.apache.org/ points to the parent doap: link

Re: [ALL] DOAP file placement - move out of trunk?

2013-03-12 Thread Simone Tripodi
In my humble opinion, DOAP files should be auto-generated and published to public components sites. What's the reason to distribute it in the source archive, when releasing? DOAPs are intended to be consumed by crawlers/robots/... and doesn't affect the build at all. In Apache Onami we are using

Re: [ALL] DOAP file placement - move out of trunk?

2013-03-12 Thread Benedikt Ritter
Hi Simo, 2013/3/12 Simone Tripodi simonetrip...@apache.org In my humble opinion, DOAP files should be auto-generated and published to public components sites. What's the reason to distribute it in the source archive, when releasing? DOAPs are intended to be consumed by crawlers/robots/...

Re: [ALL] DOAP file placement - move out of trunk?

2013-03-12 Thread Simone Tripodi
Hi Bene, As far as I understand, this was the intention of sebb's proposal (making sure that the DOAP doesn't get included in source distributions by moving it out of a components SVN directory). my question was a remark indeed, I was not really looking for a reply.

Re: [ALL] DOAP file placement - move out of trunk?

2013-03-12 Thread sebb
On 12 March 2013 07:26, Simone Tripodi simonetrip...@apache.org wrote: In my humble opinion, DOAP files should be auto-generated and published to public components sites. Provided that it is possible to control the contents adequately, that seems sensible. What's the reason to distribute it

[ALL] DOAP file placement - move out of trunk?

2013-03-11 Thread sebb
The DOAP files are currently held under /commons/proper/component/trunk/doap_component.rdf This is sort of convenient for editting, but means the doap file gets included in tags and branches and may get included in source. If included in source, the release date may be missing or inaccurate.

Re: [ALL] DOAP file placement - move out of trunk?

2013-03-11 Thread Stefan Bodewig
On 2013-03-12, sebb wrote: The DOAP files are currently held under /commons/proper/component/trunk/doap_component.rdf This is sort of convenient for editting, but means the doap file gets included in tags and branches and may get included in source. If included in source, the release date