Re: svn commit: r1630358 [1/6] - in /maven/plugins/trunk: maven-acr-plugin/ maven-ant-plugin/ maven-antrun-plugin/ maven-assembly-plugin/ maven-changelog-plugin/ maven-changes-plugin/ maven-checkstyle

2014-10-09 Thread Robert Scholte
Hi Karl-Heinz, there was a discussion about this: are LICENSE and NOTICE also required for the project-roots or only for the distributions? The latter is already done. Please read http://maven.markmail.org/thread/jlw4rjte2snu4tck thanks, Robert Op Thu, 09 Oct 2014 11:49:33 +0200 schreef

Re: svn commit: r1630358 [1/6] - in /maven/plugins/trunk: maven-acr-plugin/ maven-ant-plugin/ maven-antrun-plugin/ maven-assembly-plugin/ maven-changelog-plugin/ maven-changes-plugin/ maven-checkstyle

2014-10-09 Thread Karl Heinz Marbaise
Hi Robert, On 10/9/14 7:23 PM, Robert Scholte wrote: there was a discussion about this: are LICENSE and NOTICE also required for the project-roots or only for the distributions? The latter is already done. For the distribution archives i know...so you don't see the need at the momemt for

Re: svn commit: r1630358 [1/6] - in /maven/plugins/trunk: maven-acr-plugin/ maven-ant-plugin/ maven-antrun-plugin/ maven-assembly-plugin/ maven-changelog-plugin/ maven-changes-plugin/ maven-checkstyle

2014-10-09 Thread Robert Scholte
Putting them in the svn project roots would mean maintenance, e.g. the generated LICENSE auto-updates the years. For that reason I wouldn't put them there. IIRC the ASF is not very clear about it, so for that reason there hasn't been made a real decision. thanks, Robert Op Thu, 09 Oct 2014

Re: svn commit: r1630358 [1/6] - in /maven/plugins/trunk: maven-acr-plugin/ maven-ant-plugin/ maven-antrun-plugin/ maven-assembly-plugin/ maven-changelog-plugin/ maven-changes-plugin/ maven-checkstyle

2014-10-09 Thread Dennis Lundberg
If I recall correctly, we are still waiting for a response whether this is necessary or not. Personally I'm against adding these files in version control because of the unwanted maintenance, as Robert noted. Remember that we have over 100 release roots that we need to maintain. -- Dennis

Re: svn commit: r1630358 [1/6] - in /maven/plugins/trunk: maven-acr-plugin/ maven-ant-plugin/ maven-antrun-plugin/ maven-assembly-plugin/ maven-changelog-plugin/ maven-changes-plugin/ maven-checkstyle

2014-10-09 Thread Karl Heinz Marbaise
Hi, So it would be better to remove them...sorry for this... Ok...i will undo the change... Kind regards Karl Heinz Marbaise corret On 10/9/14 10:28 PM, Dennis Lundberg wrote: If I recall correctly, we are still waiting for a response whether this is necessary or not. Personally I'm

Re: svn commit: r1630358 [1/6] - in /maven/plugins/trunk: maven-acr-plugin/ maven-ant-plugin/ maven-antrun-plugin/ maven-assembly-plugin/ maven-changelog-plugin/ maven-changes-plugin/ maven-checkstyle

2014-10-09 Thread Karl Heinz Marbaise
Hi, undone the change... Kind regards Karl-Heinz Marbaise On 10/9/14 10:34 PM, Karl Heinz Marbaise wrote: Hi, So it would be better to remove them...sorry for this... Ok...i will undo the change... Kind regards Karl Heinz Marbaise corret On 10/9/14 10:28 PM, Dennis Lundberg wrote: If I