Re: MyFaces Commons project: aliasBean

2007-10-24 Thread Martin Marinschek
Alias-Bean works with RI as well, but not if you use component bindings. The problem why it doesn't work is an ommission in the spec - bindings are restored out of the JSF-request-lifecycle, outside of a tree iteration. I have (a long time ago) filed a bug against the spec with regards to this - i

Re: MyFaces Commons project: aliasBean

2007-10-24 Thread Volker Weber
Hi, i think i should recheck using aliasBean in tobago, if i remember correct it works as a container component and the alias is valid for all children. It should be possible in tobago having a extra container around a component. Regards, Volker 2007/10/24, Mario Ivankovits <[EMAIL PROTECTE

Re: MyFaces Commons project: aliasBean

2007-10-24 Thread Mike Kienenberger
Well, if aliasBean only works with Myfaces Core, I wonder why we even include it with Tomahawk. It sounds like it should really be an extension point of MyFaces Core. In any case, it doesn't sound like a candidate for MyFaces commons at present. On 10/24/07, Volker Weber <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrot

Re: MyFaces Commons project: aliasBean

2007-10-24 Thread Volker Weber
Hi Mike, in general i'm +1 for aliasBean into the commons project, it just did not fit into tobago. But there is a problem: afaik aliasBean did not work with RI. The myfaces lifecycleImpl has a special handling of BindingAware interface components, which are afaik only aliasBean and aliasBeanScop

Re: MyFaces Commons project: aliasBean

2007-10-24 Thread Mario Ivankovits
Hi! > Why wouldn't aliasBean work as a commons project component? I > haven't looked at the implementation, but at first glance of the docs, > it doesn't seem to do anything renderkit-specific. > I think their problem is that you can use the aliasBeansScope (for example) to group components to

MyFaces Commons project: aliasBean

2007-10-24 Thread Mike Kienenberger
Why wouldn't aliasBean work as a commons project component? I haven't looked at the implementation, but at first glance of the docs, it doesn't seem to do anything renderkit-specific. I looked at the renderer implementation and it simply looks like its being used as a callback hook back into th