Re: [Elecraft] Can a 1N4007 Be an Effective Relay Snubber?

2009-05-13 Thread Jack Smith
Any of the 1N400x series work well for this purpose. I've slowly learned the lesson that as a very small kit provider that it's often cheaper to use the same part in multiple kits even though it may be over-rated for some applications because the increased volume reduces the price, fewer stock

Re: [Elecraft] Can a 1N4007 Be an Effective Relay Snubber?

2009-05-13 Thread Sandy
:54 PM Subject: Re: [Elecraft] Can a 1N4007 Be an Effective Relay Snubber? On Apr 8, 2009, at 2:22 PM, Jack Smith wrote: The Cliff's Notes version is that the turn-on (note I said turn-on, not turn-off) time of a 1N4007 diode is sufficiently fast to be a very effective relay snubber

Re: [Elecraft] Can a 1N4007 Be an Effective Relay Snubber?

2009-05-12 Thread Bill Coleman
On Apr 8, 2009, at 2:22 PM, Jack Smith wrote: The Cliff's Notes version is that the turn-on (note I said turn-on, not turn-off) time of a 1N4007 diode is sufficiently fast to be a very effective relay snubber. Interesting! It's always true that experiment trumps theory. Curious, though,

[Elecraft] Can a 1N4007 Be an Effective Relay Snubber?

2009-04-08 Thread Jack Smith
To answer, I hope definitively, the question is a 1N4007 power diode too slow to be used as a relay coil snubber, I've updated my December 2007 diode turn-on time measurements with data taken this morning showing the effectiveness of (a) no snubber; (b) 1N4148 snubber and (c) 1N4007 snubber

Re: [Elecraft] Can a 1N4007 Be an Effective Relay Snubber?

2009-04-08 Thread Sandy
and no more problems! 73, Sandy W5TVW - Original Message - From: Jack Smith jack.sm...@cliftonlaboratories.com To: 'Elecraft' elecraft@mailman.qth.net Sent: Wednesday, April 08, 2009 1:22 PM Subject: [Elecraft] Can a 1N4007 Be an Effective Relay Snubber? To answer, I hope

Re: [Elecraft] Can a 1N4007 Be an Effective Relay Snubber?

2009-04-08 Thread Paul Christensen
To answer, I hope definitively, the question is a 1N4007 power diode too slow to be used as a relay coil snubber, Just curious -- over the years, I've seen references to the main purpose of the snubber diode being used; (1) to decrease the action time of the relay, since the decaying flux of

Re: [Elecraft] Can a 1N4007 Be an Effective Relay Snubber?

2009-04-08 Thread Jack Smith
The quick test I did today used a common 2N7000 MOSFET to switch a physically small relay typical of those used in ham gear. I think this is a reasonably common arrangement and I've used it in the past myself. The turn-off voltage exceeds the 2N7000's maximum permitted source-drain voltage of

Re: [Elecraft] Can a 1N4007 Be an Effective Relay Snubber?

2009-04-08 Thread Mel Farrer
jack.sm...@cliftonlaboratories.com Subject: Re: [Elecraft] Can a 1N4007 Be an Effective Relay Snubber? To: Paul Christensen w...@arrl.net Cc: 'Elecraft' elecraft@mailman.qth.net Date: Wednesday, April 8, 2009, 2:43 PM The quick test I did today used a common 2N7000 MOSFET to switch a physically small

Re: [Elecraft] Can a 1N4007 Be an Effective Relay Snubber? [END of Thread]

2009-04-08 Thread Eric Swartz - WA6HHQ, Elecraft
Let's end this thread for now. I think we've pretty much beaten it to death. ;-) 73, Eric WA6HHQ Elecraft List Moderator __ Elecraft mailing list Home: http://mailman.qth.net/mailman/listinfo/elecraft Help:

Re: [Elecraft] Can a 1N4007 Be an Effective Relay Snubber?

2009-04-08 Thread Sandy
' elecraft@mailman.qth.net Sent: Wednesday, April 08, 2009 4:11 PM Subject: Re: [Elecraft] Can a 1N4007 Be an Effective Relay Snubber? To answer, I hope definitively, the question is a 1N4007 power diode too slow to be used as a relay coil snubber, Just curious -- over the years, I've seen