Re: [fossil-users] File moves reported in commit as file deletion!

2012-12-17 Thread Richard Hipp
On Sun, Dec 16, 2012 at 11:56 PM, K k...@lightpowered.org wrote: Hello, I've done a number of fossil mv file.h source/code/ today, then issued a commit. The check-in reports that all of the files I've moved have been deleted and renamed. For example: Deleted foo.c version

Re: [fossil-users] File moves reported in commit as file deletion!

2012-12-17 Thread Derrick Moser
-scm.org Sent: Monday, 17 December 2012, 8:39 Subject: Re: [fossil-users] File moves reported in commit as file deletion! On Sun, Dec 16, 2012 at 11:56 PM, K k...@lightpowered.org wrote: Hello, I've done a number of fossil mv file.h source/code/ today, then issued a commit. The check

Re: [fossil-users] File moves reported in commit as file deletion!

2012-12-17 Thread K
on Dec 17, 2012, Richard Hipp d...@sqlite.org wrote: On Sun, Dec 16, 2012 at 11:56 PM, K k...@lightpowered.org wrote: Hello, I've done a number of fossil mv file.h source/code/ today, then issued a commit. The check-in reports that all of the files I've moved have been deleted and

Re: [fossil-users] File moves reported in commit as file deletion!

2012-12-17 Thread Richard Hipp
On Mon, Dec 17, 2012 at 2:55 PM, K k...@lightpowered.org wrote: I'm looking at the page for my file and its history ends as deleted when I did not delete it. I moved it, which fossil changes reported as a RENAMED. I commited and now have the surprise dumped on me that my file was deleted and

Re: [fossil-users] File moves reported in commit as file deletion!

2012-12-17 Thread K
As I said, I did not DELETE any files, but rather moved them. fossil changes reported them as RENAMED. And in the check in, they are being reported as DELETED. I'm just asking how in the design of Fossil you justified this decision. Please directly address this vs skirting it. ^K on Dec

Re: [fossil-users] File moves reported in commit as file deletion!

2012-12-17 Thread Richard Hipp
On Mon, Dec 17, 2012 at 3:49 PM, K k...@lightpowered.org wrote: As I said, I did not DELETE any files, but rather moved them. fossil changes reported them as RENAMED. And in the check in, they are being reported as DELETED. I'm just asking how in the design of Fossil you justified this

Re: [fossil-users] File moves reported in commit as file deletion!

2012-12-17 Thread K
I don't need to make assumptions, and therefore am not. I'm going off of the facts, which I can observe, and which I can present to others. The file was not deleted. It was moved using Fossil's own fossil mv command. It's irrational to treat this as a deletion. If you cannot provide

Re: [fossil-users] File moves reported in commit as file deletion!

2012-12-17 Thread Themba Fletcher
On Mon, Dec 17, 2012 at 12:58 PM, K k...@lightpowered.org wrote: If you cannot provide justification for this behavior snip I'm a bit confused by the tone of some of the messages on the list lately. This could have as easily been worded as a polite bug report, but instead comes across as

Re: [fossil-users] File moves reported in commit as file deletion!

2012-12-17 Thread K
When some arbitrary decision/value such as a minimum length of wiki pages imposes itself for no rational reason on my workflow, and I'm told by the maintainer to maintain a separate personal branch rather than this being changed in the main source, I started leaving my Richard Hipp fan club

Re: [fossil-users] File moves reported in commit as file deletion!

2012-12-17 Thread Michael Richter
You know, for someone using a tool that hasn't paid for it, you have a real tone of overweening entitlement. Perhaps you need to look up the definitions involved in free software and open source software. You may wish, in particular, to pay attention to the portions of it that involve how to get

Re: [fossil-users] File moves reported in commit as file deletion!

2012-12-17 Thread K
Thanks for sharing! ^K on Dec 17, 2012, Michael Richter ttmrich...@gmail.com wrote: You know, for someone using a tool that hasn't paid for it, you have a real tone of overweening entitlement. Perhaps you need to look up the definitions involved in free software and open source software.

[fossil-users] File moves reported in commit as file deletion!

2012-12-16 Thread K
Hello, I've done a number of fossil mv file.h source/code/ today, then issued a commit. The check-in reports that all of the files I've moved have been deleted and renamed. For example: Deleted foo.c version [0e52b8b63a1e8c0d] Name change from from foo.c to source/code/foo.c. Why is a file