Re: [FRIAM] Privacy vs Open Public Data

2013-01-17 Thread lrudolph
Nick speaks for himself: We are, by immigration, probably a nation of former thieves, cutpurses, embezzlers, for whom the choice was the docks or the stocks. You, sir, I believe, are from a sub-nation of former religious fanatics. I am partly that, but mostly from the (large!) sub-nation

Re: [FRIAM] [EXTERNAL] Re: Privacy vs Open Public Data

2013-01-17 Thread lrudolph
Nick avers: I guess I am a behaviorist about shame. If my behavior makes me blush than it was shameful. Alternatively, someone has slipped you a large dose of niacin, which has made you blush, which you have felt as shame. I suggested this several times to Jim Laird as a worthwhile

Re: [FRIAM] Dropbox big-time

2013-01-17 Thread Owen Densmore
A bit OT but ... Hmm.. Just got thinking about about Amazon being used by Dropbox and their relative pricing. Amazon charges $.095/GB/Month for its storage. That's $9.50/Mo or $114.00/Year for 100GB. http://aws.amazon.com/s3/pricing/ 100GB is the first tier of paid Dropbox which goes for

Re: [FRIAM] here we go

2013-01-17 Thread glen
I applaud your attempt to expand out to the forest layer! But I still think you're being overly specific about our disagreement. My summary about dissimilarity as the common cause for the communication illusion and tool abuse failed to capture the core disagreement, I suppose. So, I'll try

Re: [FRIAM] Dropbox big-time

2013-01-17 Thread Ron Newman
Aq looks great, esp. the retention of metadata (file dates). If only it supported Windows. On Thu, Jan 17, 2013 at 8:36 AM, Owen Densmore o...@backspaces.net wrote: A bit OT but ... Hmm.. Just got thinking about about Amazon being used by Dropbox and their relative pricing. Amazon charges

Re: [FRIAM] [EXTERNAL] Re: Privacy vs Open Public Data

2013-01-17 Thread Parks, Raymond
I prefer embarrassed to shamed - perhaps there's a spectrum from proud to embarrassed to shamed to guilty. Perhaps white lies do not grease your part of the wheels of society - but I'm reasonably sure, based on my experience, that they are in use in many societies including ours. There's the

Re: [FRIAM] Privacy vs Open Public Data

2013-01-17 Thread glen
Marcus G. Daniels wrote at 01/16/2013 07:17 PM: It should be public. But it is rude to press a person for personal facts they don't volunteer. If someone uses a source, whether it is convenient or inconvenient, public or something else, they they then have no business making you feel

Re: [FRIAM] [EXTERNAL] Re: Privacy vs Open Public Data

2013-01-17 Thread glen
Parks, Raymond wrote at 01/17/2013 10:19 AM: These are all proof that we lie frequently in order to grease the wheels of society. Isn't it something like a false distinction to call all this lying? After all, we have von Neumann's extrapolation of Tarski's (or perhaps Goedel's) work claiming

Re: [FRIAM] [EXTERNAL] Re: Privacy vs Open Public Data

2013-01-17 Thread Parks, Raymond
Yes, we lie frequently. Yes, it is lying - we are either stating a falsehood or omitting the truth (the atheist example upthread). Human beings are social animals - we constantly try to manipulate our social situation for our personal optimum - it's built into us. Some of us are better at it

Re: [FRIAM] Privacy vs Open Public Data

2013-01-17 Thread glen
Parks, Raymond wrote at 01/17/2013 10:34 AM: Yes, we lie frequently. Yes, it is lying - we are either stating a falsehood or omitting the truth (the atheist example upthread). Human beings are social animals - we constantly try to manipulate our social situation for our personal optimum -

Re: [FRIAM] Privacy vs Open Public Data

2013-01-17 Thread Douglas Roberts
Even I can detect a willful argumentative bent here. Ray said, and I quote: Yes, we lie frequently. You said, OK. Well, if we're all always lying, [...] Now now, you know better... --Doug On Thu, Jan 17, 2013 at 11:42 AM, glen g...@ropella.name wrote: Parks, Raymond wrote at 01/17/2013

Re: [FRIAM] [EXTERNAL] Re: Privacy vs Open Public Data

2013-01-17 Thread Marcus G. Daniels
On 1/17/13 11:19 AM, Parks, Raymond wrote: There's the blatant pretense of privacy that Marcus mentioned exists in Japan. It was Bruce that made this point. This article elaborates.. http://biblioteca.clacso.edu.ar/ar/libros/raec/ethicomp5/docs/htm_papers/52Orito,%20Yohko.htm Within the

Re: [FRIAM] Privacy vs Open Public Data

2013-01-17 Thread glen
No, I asserted that if we follow Ray's claim to its logical conclusion, it means we are always lying. He responded Yes, but then went on to ignore the flaw in his argument. So, I'm reinforcing my point that his argument is flawed and he hasn't refuted it. That's not argumentative. It's good

Re: [FRIAM] Privacy vs Open Public Data

2013-01-17 Thread Douglas Roberts
Clever. Objection overruled. (We watched the Lincoln Lawyer last night). On Thu, Jan 17, 2013 at 11:59 AM, glen g...@ropella.name wrote: No, I asserted that if we follow Ray's claim to its logical conclusion, it means we are always lying. He responded Yes, but then went on to ignore the

[FRIAM] It looks like this will be a daily event for a while

2013-01-17 Thread Douglas Roberts
Maybe Linux Today will pick up another one, that's worth about 2,000 hits. http://things-linux.blogspot.com/2013/01/interesting-priorities.html -- *Doug Roberts drobe...@rti.org d...@parrot-farm.net* *http://parrot-farm.net/Second-Cousins*http://parrot-farm.net/Second-Cousins *

Re: [FRIAM] [EXTERNAL] Re: Privacy vs Open Public Data

2013-01-17 Thread Nicholas Thompson
Sorry. I wasn't asking whether we lie or not. Or even whether it eases some social situations. I was asking for a theory of why lying greases social situations. Why is the NET effect of small lies positive? I can think of some reasons. Like chimpanzees, we live in a fision-fusion situation.

Re: [FRIAM] Dropbox big-time

2013-01-17 Thread Gillian Densmore
I love google drive for somestuff- It's great if you can use it from the same computer or have one that does java quickly when uploading at school though for some reason it was dog slow-same for downloading-and that stuff was-illustrator files- or pictures--with those short comings acounted for

Re: [FRIAM] It looks like this will be a daily event for a while

2013-01-17 Thread Nicholas Thompson
Doug, My experience with Google is that because so much of their stuff is given away, their Do No Evil has metamorphosed into How could we possibly do evil? we're such nice people! I don't get the feeling they are embarrassed when one of their apps turns out to be crap. But I am not a Beta

Re: [FRIAM] It looks like this will be a daily event for a while

2013-01-17 Thread Douglas Roberts
Nick, Re: free stuff being crap, well, that's one thing I guess. However I paid $349 for my pretty Gorilla Glass brick with a blinking blue led. And the fact that you don't know what you're talking about really does set you apart from the rest of this list. /sarcasm --Doug On Thu, Jan 17,

Re: [FRIAM] here we go

2013-01-17 Thread Steve Smith
Glen - Thanks for the continued engagement. We may not be converging on any agreement but we might be approaching a common language. Here is an outline of the issues in our discussion as I see them: 1. Is concept space discrete or continuous (Axiom of Choice vs Landscape)? 2. What is the

Re: [FRIAM] [EXTERNAL] Re: Privacy vs Open Public Data

2013-01-17 Thread Steve Smith
Nick - Sorry. I wasn't asking whether we lie or not. Or even whether it eases some social situations. I was asking for a theory of why lying greases social situations. Why is the NET effect of small lies positive? I can think of some reasons. Like chimpanzees, we live in a fision-fusion

Re: [FRIAM] [EXTERNAL] Re: Privacy vs Open Public Data

2013-01-17 Thread Parks, Raymond
Humans lie but not everything a human says is a lie. If your sample size is conversation rather than word, then you can safely say humans always lie. Otherwise, you're straying into politician lying joke territory. Ray Parks Consilient Heuristician/IDART Program Manager V: 505-844-4024 M:

Re: [FRIAM] here we go

2013-01-17 Thread glen
Nice! You wax poetic in the latter part, which I'm incapable of paralleling. But I'll try to mimic the spirit. Steve Smith wrote at 01/17/2013 12:40 PM: 1. Is concept space discrete or continuous (Axiom of Choice vs Landscape)? 2. What is the relationship between humanity and technology? 3.

Re: [FRIAM] [EXTERNAL] Re: Privacy vs Open Public Data

2013-01-17 Thread Parks, Raymond
Nick, My point is that there are things we do not want to be public that are not illegal nor shameful. An example of such a thing is a behavior or statement that seems to contradict one's relationship with another human. It's perfectly reasonable, but that other human can and frequently

Re: [FRIAM] [EXTERNAL] Re: Privacy vs Open Public Data

2013-01-17 Thread Nicholas Thompson
Ah. The equivalent of the bank Robbers mask. Jam the camera. N From: Friam [mailto:friam-boun...@redfish.com] On Behalf Of Parks, Raymond Sent: Thursday, January 17, 2013 3:26 PM To: The Friday Morning Applied Complexity Coffee Group Subject: Re: [FRIAM] [EXTERNAL] Re: Privacy vs Open

Re: [FRIAM] [EXTERNAL] Re: Privacy vs Open Public Data

2013-01-17 Thread lrudolph
Why stop at jam the camera? *Spoof* the camera (feed it false but plausible data, perhaps inculpating someone else, or perhaps just showing an uppity empty Naugahyde `:chair): a real- time, animated analogue of the photoshopped stills we now have learned to expect everywhere. Ah. The

Re: [FRIAM] [EXTERNAL] Re: Privacy vs Open Public Data

2013-01-17 Thread Parks, Raymond
I don't have any real information nor the inclination to do the research, but odds are that huge surveillance camera rollouts (as in city-wide) are IP not analog cameras. Since running cables is so expensive, they probably use either wireless (GSM) to the monitoring center or at least wireless