Re: [DISCUSS] SQLLine as a sub-project of DB

2022-04-01 Thread Craig Russell
Makes sense to me. Yes, I know it's 4/1 but I would support this proposal. Craig > On Apr 1, 2022, at 5:44 PM, Julian Hyde wrote: > > Going through the incubator makes sense. I would probably be champion and a > mentor, and given the experience of the project members, there’s not much >

Re: [DISCUSS] SQLLine as a sub-project of DB

2022-04-01 Thread Julian Hyde
Going through the incubator makes sense. I would probably be champion and a mentor, and given the experience of the project members, there’s not much Apache Way to be taught. We can complete the necessary admin tasks (IP check, name search, etc.) and make a release via the Incubator. In the

Re: [DISCUSS] SQLLine as a sub-project of DB

2022-04-01 Thread Craig Russell
Hi, The hard part about bringing in sub-projects is what the incubator focuses on: importing the code base into apache repositories getting the proper licensing in place for the code making releases with attention to vetting, voting, and staging working as a community If we have suitable mentors

Re: [DISCUSS] SQLLine as a sub-project of DB

2022-04-01 Thread Julian Hyde
Petri seems to be intended for prospective top-level projects, and for projects that have no experience with the Apache Way. Neither of those are true for SQLLine. I would like to hear Craig’s opinion in light of the discovery that the bylaws allow the PMC to create sub-projects. > On Apr 1,

Re: [DISCUSS] SQLLine as a sub-project of DB

2022-04-01 Thread Rick Hillegas
I would be happy to call a vote on adding SQLLine as a DB sub-project. However, it seems to me that SQLLine must first pass the hurdles of some process which verifies its community support and IP. If Craig thinks that Petri is an adequate fast-track process, then that sounds like the next

Re: [DISCUSS] SQLLine as a sub-project of DB

2022-04-01 Thread Julian Hyde
By the way, I know that DB is due to send a report for this month's ASF Board meeting. I think it would be appropriate to mention that SQLLine has approached the project with a view to joining as a sub-project. On 2022/04/01 20:07:18 Julian Hyde wrote: > Thanks for raising this, Carl. I think

Re: [DISCUSS] SQLLine as a sub-project of DB

2022-04-01 Thread Julian Hyde
Thanks for raising this, Carl. I think the SQLLine project members would be interested in joining the DB project by this means. Given the members' experience with Apache this low-friction approach makes sense. Julian On 2022/03/30 19:25:11 Carl Steinbach wrote: > I'm a longtime user of both