Re: globalff.el --- Global find file

2006-03-29 Thread Richard Stallman
Well, I'm posting from Google Groups where I have little control over the formatting of the message So don't do that, then. Seriously, can't your machine send mail some other way? ___ gnu-emacs-sources mailing list gnu-emacs-sources@gnu.org

Re: A Windows style file deletion system

2006-05-27 Thread Richard Stallman
Please do not call this Windows-style. This feature existed long before Microsoft Windows. Please do not give Microsoft credit for something it did not even do. ___ gnu-emacs-sources mailing list gnu-emacs-sources@gnu.org

Re: file-props.el

2006-06-29 Thread Richard Stallman
Instead of the comma thing you could do multiple completing-reads until the user gives empty input. This way multiple tags could be entered with the ability to complete individual tags. That would be really inconvenient in practical use. It would be better to use a single minibuffer

Re: Calendar hack: Displaying ISO weeks, update for emacs 22, the real update

2006-12-07 Thread Richard Stallman
How do you know that the holidays are correct when the calendar has more than 3 months? Do you have a way to check, say, the dates of lunar phases, Easter, Chinese New Year, Yom Kippur, Islamic New Year, solstices/equinoxes? You will see SOME holidays (or diary entries) but

Re: Calendar hack: Displaying ISO weeks, update for emacs 22, the real update

2006-12-07 Thread Richard Stallman
The test (if ( displayed-month 5) checks if the center of the 3 month window is beyond May, in which case (as the comment from my code says!) Ash Wednesday, Good Friday, and Easter cannot be visibible because they occur in Feb/Mar/Apr. It sounds like we should

Re: tc.el --- timid completion

2007-02-26 Thread Richard Stallman
;;; tc.el --- timid completion ;; Copyright (C) 2007 Free Software Foundation, Inc. Has this actually been assigned to the FSF? I took a quick look in the FSF copyright.list file and did not see it. Good point. This has not been assigned, not yet.

Re: imagetext.el -- view text comments in image-mode

2007-05-19 Thread Richard Stallman
Instead of developing this as a separate package, please write it as a change to the existing code in image-mode.el, and install it in the trunk. ___ gnu-emacs-sources mailing list gnu-emacs-sources@gnu.org

Re: Recoverable File Deletion System

2007-05-23 Thread Richard Stallman
Since last year we have been trying to set up the Emacs 22.1 release and not installing any new features. We don't want to put in any Windows-only features, since our goal is to eliminate proprietary systems, not enhance them. However, if the feature also works on GNU/Linux, then we might want

Re: Recoverable File Deletion System

2007-05-27 Thread Richard Stallman
Richard, founder of this wonderful piece of software that permeates my life, (ie, I'm asking this with honest curiousity) Davin asked why his code was or was not given consideration for inclusion on the windows specific URL for questions about the windows specific distribution of

Re: [OT] free software vs open source was: Re: codesearch.el 1.0 --- Search for code via Google Code Search

2007-06-30 Thread Richard Stallman
From what I've read I'd expect that free software is a subset of open source software (i.e. not all open source software is free in the sense that it protects our freedoms). That looks like a common misunderstanding, based on confusing free with copyleft. A license is a free software

Re: realplay.el interface with Real Player v. 1879

2007-06-30 Thread Richard Stallman
My understanding is that RealPlayer uses secret codecs. Only reverse-engineering makes it possible to write free decoders. And I think they change the codecs frequently. Thus, we need to pressure sites that use RealPlayer format to stop using it and switch to a public standard format.

Re: realplay.el interface with Real Player v. 1879

2007-07-01 Thread Richard Stallman
Yes there is the Helix Player which is GPL if I recall properly. Helix is the top level of RealPlayer. I recall that its license is something unusual, not the GNU GPL, and I do not recall whether it is a free license. But I am sure that it only handles the container level. It has to call

Re: [OT] free software vs open source was: Re: codesearch.el 1.0 --- Search for code via Google Code Search

2007-07-02 Thread Richard Stallman
thanks for the clarification. Essentially, I agree. My only concern is that old problem of the understanding of 'free'. The vast majority of people I hear using the term 'free software' are almost always talking about free of cost rather than free as in freedom. Both terms are

Re: realplay.el interface with Real Player v. 1879

2007-07-18 Thread Richard Stallman
You (the GNU project) already does so with EMMS. What is EMMS, and how does EMMS relate to mplayer? It's an Emacs interface to various command line media players. It also has a lot of features you would expect from a full blown GUI media player, like playlists,

Re: realplay.el interface with Real Player v. 1879

2007-07-18 Thread Richard Stallman
Many others aim to convince people to migrate to GNU/Linux, often by forgetting about freedom as a goal. That may be what you are doing here. Free software somehow has to interact with the real world, I am just as aware of that as you are. Where we may disagree is in the

Re: [OT] Re: realplay.el interface with Real Player v. 1879

2007-07-19 Thread Richard Stallman
You're wrong, EMMS is indeed a GNU project. It seems that EMMS is a GNU package--a separate one. I will look at the situation with EMMS and mplayer. ___ gnu-emacs-sources mailing list gnu-emacs-sources@gnu.org

Re: [OT] Re: realplay.el interface with Real Player v. 1879

2007-07-20 Thread Richard Stallman
and perhaps you're missing some of the subtlety of david's point: if mplayer did not support non-free codecs, some (many) people wouldn't even consider giving GNU/Linux a try. This is exactly what I mentioned in my previous message. The mplayer approach sacrifices the appreciation of

Re: [OT] Re: realplay.el interface with Real Player v. 1879

2007-07-20 Thread Richard Stallman
The difference between Richard's and your perspective is that your approach is possibly focusing more on the usability issues and allowing users to benefit from a free platform while still being able to access proprietary content as easily as users of closed proprietary

Re: keyboard-macro-timer.el

2007-07-20 Thread Richard Stallman
For executing previous command I did some investigation and looked up how `repeat' does it and it was way too complicated to me with a lot of handling of special cases. We could move some of that code to a subroutine which you could call. That should be pretty straightforward. Having

Re: realplay.el interface with Real Player v. 1879

2007-07-20 Thread Richard Stallman
The non-free codecs that I'm talking about are the ones that are binary-only (or those that have non-free licenses; but I am not sure that case occurs). I don't see any ethical problem in distributing programs that are patented or illegal in certain countries, as long as

Re: [OT] Re: realplay.el interface with Real Player v. 1879

2007-07-20 Thread Richard Stallman
It seems that EMMS is a GNU package--a separate one. I will look at the situation with EMMS and mplayer. What do you mean by situation? It means, the relevant facts. I don't want to reach a premature conclusion. Which means that EMMS tries mpg321 (for mp3s), ogg123 (for ogg

Re: [OT] Re: realplay.el interface with Real Player v. 1879

2007-07-20 Thread Richard Stallman
The fact a piece of free software allows you to use non-free software/codecs in itself is not an issue. Rather its the extent to which it facilitates doing so that is of concern. the FSF isn't so ideological as to try and ban the use of free software - if they were, you

Re: realplay.el interface with Real Player v. 1879

2007-07-22 Thread Richard Stallman
Then please have a look at the *long* list of supported codecs by the free libavcodec. They did a lot for your goals. Maybe they did -- I don't know. But even if that is true, it is just one factor in the decision about mplayer. The most important factor is that we must not act as if

Re: [OT] Re: realplay.el interface with Real Player v. 1879

2007-07-23 Thread Richard Stallman
i'm not familiar enough with the start of the open source movement, but the way i've always understood it is that those who started it did not have the goal of bringing the message of free software to the larger public, but rather the message of open source (which, as you probably

Re: install-elisp.el --- Simple Emacs Lisp installer using curl

2007-07-25 Thread Richard Stallman
wget is a GNU package, so we would rather use that. Can you make it use wget? ___ gnu-emacs-sources mailing list gnu-emacs-sources@gnu.org http://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/gnu-emacs-sources

Re: install-elisp.el --- Simple Emacs Lisp installer using curl

2007-07-26 Thread Richard Stallman
Given that Emacs now has url-retrieve, I don't see any reason to make provision for any other method. ___ gnu-emacs-sources mailing list gnu-emacs-sources@gnu.org http://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/gnu-emacs-sources

Re: [OT] Re: realplay.el interface with Real Player v. 1879

2007-07-26 Thread Richard Stallman
I'm an Oracle professional. I don't see any free software close to as good as their database software. By using Oracle, you're giving up your freedom. It may be convenient, or even profitable, but it isn't right. Its a fairly easy argument to make that if all software were

Re: [OT] Re: realplay.el interface with Real Player v. 1879

2007-07-27 Thread Richard Stallman
Someone else pointed out that you can't be sure of that conclusion. In that other world What other world? The hypothetical world in which proprietary software does not exist and therefore the company Oracle with its actual business model does not exist either. Someone else

Re: [OT] Re: realplay.el interface with Real Player v. 1879

2007-07-27 Thread Richard Stallman
There are plenty of people who pay for cable service instead of funding their own cable lines, yet, your argument could be turned on them and be stated, Perhaps you have misunderstood what our arguments are. Cables and software are very different. You can copy software with your

Re: anything is del.icio.us

2007-09-03 Thread Richard Stallman
What is now called ``Emacs 23'' is no longer the Unicode branch, but the trunk (which is in version 23.0.50, not .51). Since the trunk now says 23.0.50, and unicode-2 says 23.0.0.1, the term Emacs 23 seems confusing. I think we had best avoid that term.

Re: gspell.el - german spell and grammar checking

2007-09-27 Thread Richard Stallman
Well simply because gspell.el let the user mark the boundary of the parts of a compound word. It so needs user interaction. This is also the reason why it so far only work for TeX documents where you can put hyphenation marks, that are not printed unless the word needs

Re: facebook.el v 0.0.3

2009-10-08 Thread Richard Stallman
;;; First pass at interfacing with facebook. You must add the developers ;;; app and get your own application api-key and application secret key to ;;; use this. What is the developers app? Is that a proprietary program? It looks that way, but I cannot tell for certain.

Re: facebook.el v 0.0.3

2009-10-09 Thread Richard Stallman
On Facebook Apps are essentially just existing applications that you configure to use with your account. Adding the Developers App is essentially clicking a checkbox which enables their API for use and gives you an API key, so no more net proprietary software in the world is

Re: gtranslate.el --- google translation

2009-11-30 Thread Richard Stallman
Here is my first contribution to the open-source world, and first meaningful chunk of emacs-lisp! :-) Thanks for contributing to Emacs -- but please don't refer to our community with the term open-source. That is an amoral approach to the issue, and we disagree with it. What we do is

Re: gtranslate.el --- google translation

2009-12-01 Thread Richard Stallman
However, for bulk translations - i.e. full sentences - it is currently difficult to do otherwise. We need free software (and data) for this task. ___ gnu-emacs-sources mailing list gnu-emacs-sources@gnu.org

Re: gtranslate.el --- google translation

2009-12-01 Thread Richard Stallman
You don't get Software as a Service here, the service it does, is just not delivering software. The term Software as a Service means that the service consists of running a program for you to do your computing on your own data. ___

Re: regressive image dictionary fontification in emacs

2011-09-21 Thread Richard Stallman
promote SaaS sites in this list. See http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/who-does-that-server-really-serve.html. -- Dr Richard Stallman President, Free Software Foundation 51 Franklin St Boston MA 02110 USA www.fsf.org www.gnu.org Skype: No way! That's nonfree (freedom-denying) software. Use free

Re: regressive image dictionary fontification in emacs

2011-09-22 Thread Richard Stallman
. -- Dr Richard Stallman President, Free Software Foundation 51 Franklin St Boston MA 02110 USA www.fsf.org www.gnu.org Skype: No way! That's nonfree (freedom-denying) software. Use free telephony http://directory.fsf.org/category/tel/ ___ gnu-emacs

Re: easy-kill: drop-in replacement for kill-ring-save

2013-10-09 Thread Richard Stallman
on this github issue instead? https://github.com/leoliu/easy-kill/issues/3 Wait a minute! There is an ethical issue we need to check! Is it possible to participate in that discussion with Javascript disabled? -- Dr Richard Stallman President, Free Software Foundation 51 Franklin St Boston MA 02110 USA

Re: easy-kill: drop-in replacement for kill-ring-save

2013-10-11 Thread Richard Stallman
with Javascript disabled. Thanks for verifying this. It will be relevant when we write up a policy concerning Github. -- Dr Richard Stallman President, Free Software Foundation 51 Franklin St Boston MA 02110 USA www.fsf.org www.gnu.org Skype: No way! That's nonfree (freedom-denying) software. Use

Re: scan-info-node-length.el

2018-05-25 Thread Richard Stallman
length' or similar could offer counts > of more than just lines (e.g., using optional args). It could also ignore the Texinfo commands that occupy a whole line, such as @example and @end example. -- Dr Richard Stallman President, Free Software Foundation (https://gnu.org, https://fsf.org) Inte

Re: scan-info-node-length.el

2018-05-24 Thread Richard Stallman
t;) > (301 "Changing Files") These modes really ought to be subdiided. Ideally a node would be no more than 40 lines. Practically speaking, some do need to be longer, but if a node is 100 lines long we should try to split it up. Splitting a node well is not a mechanical task --

Re: erc-burnt-toast - Provide Windows Notification Center to erc with burnt-toast and erc-match

2020-03-03 Thread Richard Stallman
e install. -- Dr Richard Stallman Chief GNUisance of the GNU Project (https://gnu.org) Founder, Free Software Foundation (https://fsf.org) Internet Hall-of-Famer (https://internethalloffame.org)

Re: erc-burnt-toast - Provide Windows Notification Center to erc with burnt-toast and erc-match

2020-03-02 Thread Richard Stallman
? -- Dr Richard Stallman Chief GNUisance of the GNU Project (https://gnu.org) Founder, Free Software Foundation (https://fsf.org) Internet Hall-of-Famer (https://internethalloffame.org)