To Goanet -
Venantius Pinto posts for Madhav Chari:
One salient fact I wanted to point out was: to make good
music at a high level of musicianship you need to be grounded
in at least one form of music at a non trivial level (that means
within that form you would be considered a good musician
To Goanet -
Venantius Pinto wrote:
I would like to share an email response from Madhav Chari..
Rahman's orchestrator will be able to deliver work for the film, but he will
not be able to compose a piece of one hour or 45 minutes that has integrity
and complexity of structure of a modern
Thanks Rajan for coming into this thread. Hopefully we can have more of such
dignified discussions.
I am a tiny bit embarrassed that MC included me as a example in his post,
but it helps him make his point.
vjp
Hi Rajan and everyone,
I thought I made myself pretty clear that
Dear Goanetters,
I would like to share an email response from Madhav Chari to my post of Jai
Ho Rehman.
Madhav,
Thanks for continuing to engage and point towards meaningful analogies. You
succeeded in writing what we often talk about. My hope has often been that
people will be able to leverage
: Re: [Goanet] Jai Ho Rehman
Re: It is astonishing that this noise-making mediocrity is hailed as a
genius.
A. R. Rahman has been described as the Mozart of India by some.
I am no expert in his field of music but I thought Jai Ho had a catchy
tune.
Also,
The music for Bombay Dreams
really enjoyed
the music in this stage production.
I do not agree with Rajan's categorization of noise-making mediocrity.
Tim
Date: Mon, 23 Feb 2009 10:37:25 -0800
From: parri...@yahoo.com
To: goa...@goanet.org
Subject: Re: [Goanet] Jai Ho Rehman
But his music certainly does not show any
To all the Senas, Senes, Lashkars, Tigers, Mujahideens and the rest of the
terror forces, A. R. Rehman's statement at the Oscar's, I had a choice
between hate and love, I chose love and that is why I am here today, shows the
greatness of this man. Great man make right choices. Hate does not
To Goanet -
Soter wrote:
A. R. Rehman's statement at the Oscar's, I had a choice between
hate and love, I chose love and that is why I am here today, shows
the greatness of this man.
But his music certainly does not show any. It is
astonishing that this noise-making mediocrity is
The song Jai Ho was originally composed for Bollywood film Yuvraaj
by Guljar and Rehman duo, but Subhash Ghai did not like this score and
decided to drop this from his film. Since the film Yuvraj could not make
the big hit at the box office, so would have been the faith of this
song as well
