Re: [Goanet] The History-Maker and the Historian

2019-02-27 Thread Eugene Correia
i missed "nOT" and the line shuoukd read, "lSFX MAY HAVE nOT personally presided over it..." I said "progenitor" because SFX suggested it to be firced in Goa. St. Dominic is the brain behind the Inquisition. I now remember the book's name, Goa: Continuity and Change, edited by Prof Narendra

[Goanet] The History-Maker and the Historian

2019-02-26 Thread Gilbert Lawrence
How silly of me to equate the History-Maker with the Historian! Yet to get to the point, there is nothing wrong in being divorced or leaving employment or a relation under difficult circumstances.  But a prudent person would not talk about the former or related situation - positively or

Re: [Goanet] The History-Maker and the Historian

2019-02-26 Thread Eugene Correia
Gilbert deserves to have his say. His views can be debated. Teo was not polemically against SFX, but in the light of the Inquisition SFX is seen as the progenitor of thus sorry chapter in Christianity. SFX may have personally presided over it, but the Jesuits were resonsible. I heard David

[Goanet] The History-Maker and the Historian

2019-02-26 Thread Roland Francis
Gilbert has indulged in a ‘Shoot The Messenger’ exercise by confusing the roles of those who have created history and those who critically analyze what has been recorded by others. In comparing Francis Xavier with Teotónio DeSouza and even imagining them duking it out man-to-man in some