Re: [liberationtech] NSA has direct access to tech giants' systems for user data, secret ppt reveals

2013-06-07 Thread katana
Hi, NSA just $20M of budget? The same NSA that is building a data center (for processing what? =) for 869 million USD$ in Maryland? From http://www.democracynow.org/2012/4/20/exclusive_national_security_agency_whistleblower_william WILLIAM BINNEY: Well, it was called Thin Thread. I mean,

Re: [liberationtech] NSA has direct access to tech giants' systems for user data, secret ppt reveals

2013-06-07 Thread Eugen Leitl
On Fri, Jun 07, 2013 at 12:32:10PM +1200, Andrew Lewis wrote: PRISM isn't really even that illegal, as long as they discard communications considered to be American. So, as long as every TLA world wide does, and they all share the information, everything is all right? Not so fast. The NSA

Re: [liberationtech] NSA has direct access to tech giants' systems for user data, secret ppt reveals

2013-06-07 Thread Eugen Leitl
On Thu, Jun 06, 2013 at 09:23:03PM -0700, x z wrote: What surprised me is how Guardian and Washington Post cover this story. The Power Point slides looks laughable to me. Maybe I should interpret direct access to servers of firms as like when I'm typing this email I am also having *a direct

Re: [liberationtech] NSA has direct access to tech giants' systems for user data, secret ppt reveals

2013-06-07 Thread R. Jason Cronk
I tend to agree with this. Here are some things that look fishy about this leak * The $20 million budget seems paltry. Nothing gets done in government for that small amount. * The Powerpoint is amateurish (then again with no budget.) * Everybody implicated is denying it (though I

Re: [liberationtech] NSA has direct access to tech giants' systems for user data, secret ppt reveals

2013-06-07 Thread Michael Carbone
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Well the Director of National Intelligence James Clapper has defended the program, not denied it: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-22809541

Re: [liberationtech] NSA has direct access to tech giants' systems for user data, secret ppt reveals

2013-06-07 Thread Raven Jiang CX
This is just circumstantial speculation but read http://talkingpointsmemo.com/archives/2013/06/is_this_who_runs_prism.php Given Palantir's rapid expansion and aggressive recruitment, I think this guy might be onto something. I suspect that what is being described in the slides is not direct

Re: [liberationtech] NSA has direct access to tech giants' systems for user data, secret ppt reveals

2013-06-07 Thread x z
Hi all, I have the same feeling with Raven's. It appears that the PRISM program does exist, and that amateurish Power Point training material is real (so I take back my ploy or prank remark). However, none of this proves Guardian's headline claim NSA taps in to internet giants' systems to mine

[liberationtech] NSA has direct access to tech giants' systems for user data, secret ppt reveals

2013-06-06 Thread Michael Carbone
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Guardian: http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2013/jun/06/us-tech-giants-nsa-data WaPo:

Re: [liberationtech] NSA has direct access to tech giants' systems for user data, secret ppt reveals

2013-06-06 Thread Tom Ritter
On Jun 6, 2013 7:28 PM, Eduardo Robles Elvira edu...@gmail.com wrote: Hello NSA just $20M of budget? The same NSA that is building a data center (for processing what? =) for 869 million USD$ in Maryland?

Re: [liberationtech] NSA has direct access to tech giants' systems for user data, secret ppt reveals

2013-06-06 Thread Bernard Tyers - ei8fdb
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Still that figures seems awfully small. For whats involved. I've seen telco projects of a fraction the size of something like this costing £10M. Unless they've managed to get the companies to foot the majority of the bill? In that case, why would

Re: [liberationtech] NSA has direct access to tech giants' systems for user data, secret ppt reveals

2013-06-06 Thread Andrew Lewis
It might be that PRISM is merely the end user tool for use by analysts at the NSA, and that the actual gathering of info falls under another program designation, with a much larger budget. PRISM isn't really even that illegal, as long as they discard communications considered to be American.

Re: [liberationtech] NSA has direct access to tech giants' systems for user data, secret ppt reveals

2013-06-06 Thread Peter Eckersley
Of course, I was reading to fast and leaning to heavily on control+f. Anyway, 20 million annually seems like a very low number by the usual standards of efficiency in Department of Defense programs. But the NSA might already have a data storage, processing and query architecture in place that is

Re: [liberationtech] NSA has direct access to tech giants' systems for user data, secret ppt reveals

2013-06-06 Thread Peter Eckersley
Where did you get the $20m budget number from? I can't find it in any of the stories or attached materials. But I could be missing something. On 6 June 2013 16:14, x z xhzh...@gmail.com wrote: doesn't seem real to me. especially the part *direct access to servers*of firms ..., and with an

Re: [liberationtech] NSA has direct access to tech giants' systems for user data, secret ppt reveals

2013-06-06 Thread x z
What surprised me is how Guardian and Washington Post cover this story. The Power Point slides looks laughable to me. Maybe I should interpret direct access to servers of firms as like when I'm typing this email I am also having *a direct access* to Gmail's servers. This either a ploy by some

Re: [liberationtech] NSA has direct access to tech giants' systems for user data, secret ppt reveals

2013-06-06 Thread Andrew Lewis
There seems to be some confirmation via this statement from the DNI: http://www.dni.gov/index.php/newsroom/press-releases/191-press-releases-2013/869-dni-statement-on-activities-authorized-under-section-702-of-fisa On Jun 7, 2013, at 4:23 PM, x z xhzh...@gmail.com wrote: What surprised me is