Re: GNU license question (was: Application L10n)

2007-11-07 Thread Ori Idan
Well, this is the greatness of GPL that it demands publishing your source code. -- Ori Idan On Nov 7, 2007 9:36 AM, Michael Sternberg [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I agree that GPL is great and know that GPL applications can be commercial. The problem is that it demands to publish your

Re: GNU license question (was: Application L10n)

2007-11-07 Thread Ira Abramov
Quoting Ori Idan, from the post of Wed, 07 Nov: If it is GPL, I am happy, this shows the greatness of GPL, it forces free software. actually, that's a bad way of putting things and the wrong marketing message to put up there. GPL only works happily with other free software. if you want to

Re: GNU license question (was: Application L10n)

2007-11-07 Thread Ira Abramov
Quoting Michael Sternberg, from the post of Wed, 07 Nov: It looks that if we will use libintl as DLL - we're OK, as it stated here: http://www.gnu.org/software/gettext/manual/gettext.html#Discussions Am I right ? Yes from what _we_ know. Of course your company's lawyer should be aware of it

GNU license question (was: Application L10n)

2007-11-06 Thread Michael Sternberg
Continuing thread application localization in Linux. I've checked gettext package and seems to answer all our needs for translating interface of our application on every possible platform. Actually wikipedia gives a very short and clear explanation here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gettext

Re: GNU license question (was: Application L10n)

2007-11-06 Thread Ori Idan
I am not sure but I think the gettext library is LGPL, only the tools are GPL. If it is GPL, I am happy, this shows the greatness of GPL, it forces free software. Keep in mind that GPL application does not mean free (as in free beer) application. GPL application can be commercial. -- Ori Idan

RE: GNU license question (was: Application L10n)

2007-11-06 Thread Michael Sternberg
I agree that GPL is great and know that GPL applications can be commercial. The problem is that it demands to publish your application's source code which is not acceptable in most commercial applications. But yes, as gettext site says it: libintl and libasprintf libraries are LGPL,