Re: Dependency problems after PR 1.2 update to extras builder

2010-03-31 Thread Marius Vollmer
ext Robin Burchell virot...@viroteck.net writes: Things as I understand it: - Qt 4.5 on Maemo5 had no API/ABI compatibility guarentees. - Qt 4.6 took liberal advantage of that to change and fix some rather suboptimal parts. This might have been handled better, though, with a proper soname

Re: Dependency problems after PR 1.2 update to extras builder

2010-03-31 Thread Timo Härkönen
Hi 2010/3/31 Marius Vollmer marius.voll...@nokia.com ext Robin Burchell virot...@viroteck.net writes: Things as I understand it: - Qt 4.5 on Maemo5 had no API/ABI compatibility guarentees. - Qt 4.6 took liberal advantage of that to change and fix some rather suboptimal parts. This

Re: Dependency problems after PR 1.2 update to extras builder

2010-03-30 Thread Marius Vollmer
ext Marcin Juszkiewicz mar...@juszkiewicz.com.pl writes: Is there a way of specifiying to use the older packages? No such option. The problem are the automatic generated dependencies, if I understand things right. I.e., you build against libqt4-core version 4.6.2~git20100224, and the

Re: Dependency problems after PR 1.2 update to extras builder

2010-03-30 Thread ianaré sévi
Yes, that's what I ended up doing, since I'm building using MADDE it's qt 4.5 anyway. Package was built OK by the extras build server and I was able to install the package on the device. However it is unstable and seems to crash for no apparent reason. I was able to install the 386 version on

Re: Dependency problems after PR 1.2 update to extras builder

2010-03-30 Thread Andrew Flegg
On Mon, Mar 29, 2010 at 15:37, ianaré sévi ian...@gmail.com wrote: After making some updates to my package and putting it up on extras-devel, it won't update on the device from the repository. I was able to install it on scratchbox (both prior to and after updating the SDK). So, AIUI (and

Re: Dependency problems after PR 1.2 update to extras builder

2010-03-30 Thread Niels Breet
On Tue, March 30, 2010 15:56, Andrew Flegg wrote: On Mon, Mar 29, 2010 at 15:37, ianaré sévi ian...@gmail.com wrote: After making some updates to my package and putting it up on extras-devel, it won't update on the device from the repository. I was able to install it on scratchbox (both

Re: Dependency problems after PR 1.2 update to extras builder

2010-03-30 Thread ianaré sévi
Thanks for the clarifications. I can certainly sympathize with your situation, but in the future it might be better to hold off on updating the autobuilder until you get a firm release date from Nokia. The present situation would be much better if we knew how long we had to wait until our packages

Re: Dependency problems after PR 1.2 update to extras builder

2010-03-30 Thread Dave Neary
Hi, Niels Breet wrote: The issue people see is that they are then trying to install the PR1.2 built application on a pre PR1.2 device. This might or might not work, depending on which dependencies are specified. To summarise, from the point of view of a developer: * If I upload a new

Re: Dependency problems after PR 1.2 update to extras builder

2010-03-30 Thread Robin Burchell
On Tue, Mar 30, 2010 at 4:12 PM, ianaré sévi ian...@gmail.com wrote: Thanks for the clarifications. I can certainly sympathize with your situation, but in the future it might be better to hold off on updating the autobuilder until you get a firm release date from Nokia. Unfortunately, they

Re: Dependency problems after PR 1.2 update to extras builder

2010-03-30 Thread Andrew Flegg
On Tue, Mar 30, 2010 at 16:20, Dave Neary dne...@maemo.org wrote: [snip] And from the point of view of a user, an application which was previously available is no longer available if the developer has tried to update it recently? I don't really understand why uploading an app to

Re: Dependency problems after PR 1.2 update to extras builder

2010-03-30 Thread Andrew Flegg
On Tue, Mar 30, 2010 at 16:23, Robin Burchell virot...@viroteck.net wrote: [snip] To the best of my knowledge (from talking to Qt on Maemo folks), there is now API/ABI stability, and as such, this shouldn't cause issues again. This isn't an issue only affecting Qt apps, though - as Qt isn't

Re: Dependency problems after PR 1.2 update to extras builder

2010-03-30 Thread Robin Burchell
On Tue, Mar 30, 2010 at 4:26 PM, Andrew Flegg and...@bleb.org wrote: This isn't an issue only affecting Qt apps, though - as Qt isn't the only change in PR1.2. Indeed, Hildon has had new symbols added to support HildonLiveSearch[1][2] and this is what causes the libhildon (= 2.2.10) Depends.

Re: Dependency problems after PR 1.2 update to extras builder

2010-03-30 Thread Ram Kurvakat
Kurvakat Sent: 03/29/10 06:07 PM To: ianaré sévi, Dave Neary Subject: Re: Dependency problems after PR 1.2 update to extras builder would building QT4.6 apps by linking with libqt4-maemo5* still work ? AFAIK , these libqt4-maemo5* are still being kept for QT4.7 development. Now if that is true, atleast

Dependency problems after PR 1.2 update to extras builder

2010-03-29 Thread ianaré sévi
Hi all, After making some updates to my package and putting it up on extras-devel, it won't update on the device from the repository. I was able to install it on scratchbox (both prior to and after updating the SDK). Here are the missing dependencies : libqt4-core (= 4.6.2~git20100224)

Re: Dependency problems after PR 1.2 update to extras builder

2010-03-29 Thread Marcin Juszkiewicz
Dnia poniedziałek, 29 marca 2010 o 16:37:54 ianaré sévi napisał(a): After making some updates to my package and putting it up on extras-devel, it won't update on the device from the repository. I was able to install it on scratchbox (both prior to and after updating the SDK). How do I fix

Re: Dependency problems after PR 1.2 update to extras builder

2010-03-29 Thread ianaré sévi
Please tell me you're kidding. Because now my app isn't even available in the catalogue. Is there a way of specifiying to use the older packages ? Or deleting the new build from the server ? - ianaré sévi 2010/3/29 Marcin Juszkiewicz mar...@juszkiewicz.com.pl: Dnia poniedziałek, 29 marca 2010

Re: Dependency problems after PR 1.2 update to extras builder

2010-03-29 Thread Marcin Juszkiewicz
Dnia poniedziałek, 29 marca 2010 o 16:48:30 ianaré sévi napisał(a): Please tell me you're kidding. No, I am not kidding. It was discussed here on mailing list and announced that Extras autobuilder will be updated to PR 1.2 compatible SDK and that resulting packages will be installable only on

Re: Dependency problems after PR 1.2 update to extras builder

2010-03-29 Thread ianaré sévi
2010/3/29 Marcin Juszkiewicz mar...@juszkiewicz.com.pl: Dnia poniedziałek, 29 marca 2010 o 16:48:30 ianaré sévi napisał(a): Please tell me you're kidding. No, I am not kidding. It was discussed here on mailing list and announced that Extras autobuilder will be updated to PR 1.2 compatible SDK

Re: Dependency problems after PR 1.2 update to extras builder

2010-03-29 Thread Marcin Juszkiewicz
Dnia poniedziałek, 29 marca 2010 o 17:10:07 ianaré sévi napisał(a): 2010/3/29 Marcin Juszkiewicz mar...@juszkiewicz.com.pl: Dnia poniedziałek, 29 marca 2010 o 16:48:30 ianaré sévi napisał(a): Please tell me you're kidding. No, I am not kidding. It was discussed here on mailing list and

Re: Dependency problems after PR 1.2 update to extras builder

2010-03-29 Thread Dave Neary
Hi, Marcin Juszkiewicz wrote: No, I am not kidding. It was discussed here on mailing list and announced that Extras autobuilder will be updated to PR 1.2 compatible SDK and that resulting packages will be installable only on devices owned by Nokia employed people (and some from

Re: Dependency problems after PR 1.2 update to extras builder

2010-03-29 Thread ianaré sévi
OK got it to work, I simply set the Qt dependencies to 4.5 (instead of 4.6) manually instead on relying on the builder scripts ... - ianaré sévi 2010/3/29 Dave Neary dne...@maemo.org: Hi, Marcin Juszkiewicz wrote: No, I am not kidding. It was discussed here on mailing list and announced

Re: Dependency problems after PR 1.2 update to extras builder

2010-03-29 Thread Ram Kurvakat
or is this not possible ? - Original Message - From: ianaré sévi Sent: 03/29/10 05:58 PM To: Dave Neary Subject: Re: Dependency problems after PR 1.2 update to extras builder OK got it to work, I simply set the Qt dependencies to 4.5 (instead of 4.6) manually instead on relying on the builder

Re: Dependency problems after PR 1.2 update to extras builder

2010-03-29 Thread Marius Gedminas
On Mon, Mar 29, 2010 at 06:00:25PM +0200, Dave Neary wrote: Marcin Juszkiewicz wrote: No, I am not kidding. It was discussed here on mailing list and announced that Extras autobuilder will be updated to PR 1.2 compatible SDK and that resulting packages will be installable only on