Re: Tags for CPAN modules.

2007-07-10 Thread Michael G Schwern
Adam Kennedy wrote: This is a super idea. It might also be nice to allow cpan.org users the ability to associate tags (which could be overridden by the author) with modules which don't have them. That's the main problem with having tags in the META.yml. The tags can only be

Re: Tags for CPAN modules.

2007-07-10 Thread Andy Armstrong
Ken Williams wrote: I was about to chime in and say that when an author provides their own tags for their work, I think of them as keywords. The term tags has a connotation to me of user-generated labeling. For instance, in academic papers, the author (or perhaps even the conference/journal

Re: Tags for CPAN modules.

2007-07-09 Thread Gabor Szabo
On 7/8/07, Michael G Schwern [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Let's un-overload the distribution name by providing another axis by which an author can categorize their module. The single most dominant organizational tool of the web: tags. For a large, wide, decentralized library its simple and the

Re: Tags for CPAN modules.

2007-07-09 Thread Austin Schutz
On Sun, Jul 08, 2007 at 12:44:19PM -0700, Michael G Schwern wrote: One of the most common cries I hear from CPAN users is that they have trouble finding modules. A CPAN module is largely found by its distribution name. Names have to be unique and short which tends to hurt its descriptiveness.

RE: [SPAM] Re: Tags for CPAN modules.

2007-07-09 Thread Todd Rinaldo
: Monday, July 09, 2007 12:35 AM To: Michael G Schwern Cc: List - Module-Build; makemaker; [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: [SPAM] Re: Tags for CPAN modules. On 7/8/07, Michael G Schwern [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Let's un-overload the distribution name by providing another axis by which an author

Re: [SPAM] Re: Tags for CPAN modules.

2007-07-09 Thread Andy Armstrong
Todd Rinaldo wrote: So I think it's still left to a short discussion as to if/when/how the META.yml tags get used. Do they override the ones manually entered? Do they compliment them? Does one have a higher weight than the other? I imagined them on a different axis. In UI terms that'd mean

Re: Tags for CPAN modules.

2007-07-09 Thread Salve J Nilsen
Michael G Schwern wrote: [..] add a tags keyword to META.yml. Have search.cpan.org so something interesting with that extra information. What's the main difference between a tags keyword and the already-existing keywords field found in META.yml since rev 1.1?

Re: Tags for CPAN modules.

2007-07-09 Thread Ken Williams
On Jul 9, 2007, at 3:49 PM, Michael G Schwern wrote: Salve J Nilsen wrote: Michael G Schwern wrote: [..] add a tags keyword to META.yml. Have search.cpan.org so something interesting with that extra information. What's the main difference between a tags keyword and the already-existing

Re: Tags for CPAN modules.

2007-07-08 Thread Ron Savage
Hi Michael One of the most common cries I hear from CPAN users is that they have trouble finding modules. A CPAN module is largely found by its distribution name. Right! And surely we can all recall cases of surprise upon encountering useful modules whose name - at least initially - was

Re: Tags for CPAN modules.

2007-07-08 Thread Chris Dolan
On Jul 8, 2007, at 2:44 PM, Michael G Schwern wrote: One of the most common cries I hear from CPAN users is that they have trouble finding modules. A CPAN module is largely found by its distribution name. Names have to be unique and short which tends to hurt its descriptiveness.