Re: [meteorite-list] What are the FeO/MnO Ratios for the Kalahari 008, 009?

2005-08-10 Thread Adam Hupe
Dear List, An update, it looks like even though the two Kalahari lunar meteorites have completely different classifications they are paired. This makes sense since they were found just 50 meters apart. The abstract below proves this since they both share the same CRE and terrestrial ages:

Re: [meteorite-list] What are the FeO/MnO Ratios for the Kalahari 008, 009?

2005-08-10 Thread Martin Altmann
Hi Adam, I don't know strewnfield stats so well, but for the case, that they aren't fragments of the same stone, which were transported later by a mechanism, the heck I dunno which, wouldn't it be highly improbable, that two stones of a fall landed so close to each other, especially as they have

Re: [meteorite-list] What are the FeO/MnO Ratios for the Kalahari 008, 009?

2005-08-10 Thread Jeff Grossman
When this meteorite came to my attention as a member of the NomCom, warning bells went off in my head too. Enough evidence was presented to us to convince us that these were meteorites, although I expected this not to be the case, that we had to name them. But the find story is very odd. My

Re: [meteorite-list] What are the FeO/MnO Ratios for the Kalahari 008, 009?

2005-08-10 Thread Jeff Grossman
If you want to see the Kalahari 008/9 location from Google Earth, download that program from http://kh.google.com/download/earth/index.html, then take the snippet of code below, paste it into a text file, save it as kalahari.kml, and then launch the file. There must be a better way to send

Re: [meteorite-list] What are the FeO/MnO Ratios for the Kalahari 008, 009?

2005-08-10 Thread stan .
with the very old terrestrial age, is it really that much of a surprise to find diffrent analysis for a paired set of stones? Meteoirtes can weather very diffirently in diffrent locations even through they are only located a short distance away from each other, or heck, look at my favorite

RE: [meteorite-list] What are the FeO/MnO Ratios for the Kalahari 008, 009?

2005-08-10 Thread Norbert Classen
Hi Adam, Martin, Jeff, and All, First, as for Martin's question - it's not that unusual that two different sized individuals of one and the same fall land that close to each other. Take for example the 8 kilo + main mass of the SaU shergottite strewnfield (SaU 008). Other, much smaller stones

Re: [meteorite-list] What are the FeO/MnO Ratios for the Kalahari 008, 009?

2005-08-09 Thread Adam Hupe
Hi Again, I meant a terrestrial age of over 300 thousand years not 300 million which is still very old by meteoritic standards. Take Care, Adam __ Meteorite-list mailing list Meteorite-list@meteoritecentral.com

Re: [meteorite-list] What are the FeO/MnO Ratios for the Kalahari 008, 009?

2005-08-09 Thread MexicoDoug
Adam H. wrote: Two completely different classifications for two rocks found 50 meters apart? Just Curious, Adam 1. Notice all the computations, theoretical scribblings, and lab equipment, Adam ... Yes, curiosity killed these cats... (see Gary Larson cartoon link: www.diogenite.com/cat.jpg