[meteorite-list] Lunar/Martian controversy

2003-12-20 Thread Mark Jackson
Dear List, Another curiosity that I struggled with intellectually while out there on the lakes was this controversy over the find ratio of lunars to martians (It currently stands close to even, I beleive). It's easy for me to holistically contemplate that, all other things being equal, it should

Re: [meteorite-list] Lunar/Martian controversy

2003-12-20 Thread ks1u
Mark: Hello, you pose an interesting observation and question. The first thing which comes to mind is thatpredictions based on statistics are more likely to fall within predicted ranges when relatively high numbers are involved. I don't recall off-hand how many of each (lunar and Martian)

Re: [meteorite-list] Lunar/Martian controversy

2003-12-20 Thread j . divelbiss
Q: When were most space floaters from Mars and the Moon created? A: A couple billions of years ago when most of the planetary bombardments were occurring. Q: How long have these planetary meteorites been on earth? A: Probably all less than 25,000 years. So we know the rate of finds from

Re: [meteorite-list] Lunar/Martian controversy

2003-12-20 Thread Starbits
In a message dated 12/20/2003 8:24:13 AM US Mountain Standard Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Q: When were most space floaters from Mars and the Moon created? A: A couple billions of years ago when most of the planetary bombardments were occurring. Actually they are much, much

Re: AW: [meteorite-list] Lunar/Martian controversy

2003-12-20 Thread j . divelbiss
Norbert, Thanx for correction as always. This does answer reinforce the Mars material late arrival notion? Still too complicated is a start... Time, time, time... JD Hi Mark, John, and List, Since Eric already addressed an error in the first answer regarding the absolute ages of

AW: [meteorite-list] Lunar/Martian controversy

2003-12-20 Thread Norbert Classen
Hi Mark, John, and List, Since Eric already addressed an error in the first answer regarding the absolute ages of Martian, and lunar meteorites, let me address an error in the second answer: Q: How long have these planetary meteorites been on earth? A: Probably all less than 25,000 years. So

Re: [meteorite-list] Lunar/Martian controversy

2003-12-20 Thread j . divelbiss
Thanx Eric, If our max 19 million year CRE ages are correct relative to the carbon dating, then materials from the ancient impacts are not around, or at least in space or evident on Earth. Maybe on other planets...maybe. Q: Does this imply that the Asteroid Belt is out of bounds for this

Re: [meteorite-list] Lunar/Martian controversy

2003-12-20 Thread Sterling K. Webb
Hi, Just as it's hard to get to the Moon (from Earth, that is, I haven't made it yet), it's even harder to get TO the Earth FROM the Moon. Yeah, I know, it flies in the face of the obvious (Earth LOOKS flat)! There's the Moon just hanging around up there in the heavenly neighborhood,

Re: [meteorite-list] Lunar/Martian controversy

2003-12-20 Thread Sterling K. Webb
Hi, Easiest expalnation is that the moonrocks we do find on Earth have gotten here in a short timeframe. Probably zinged around in the Earth-Moon system for a while and then had the bad luck to smack us. And a short cosmic ray exposure age is a long time, at least for us humans. Tektites

Re: [meteorite-list] Lunar/Martian controversy

2003-12-20 Thread Ron Baalke
Another curiosity that I struggled with intellectually while out there on the lakes was this controversy over the find ratio of lunars to martians (It currently stands close to even, I beleive). It's easy for me to holistically contemplate that, all other things being equal, it should be