Re: orion-list Water, Water everywhere...

2002-06-23 Thread Ian Hutchesson
Dear Rochelle, I'd like to deal with two things: The cracked cistern --- Parenthetically, the so-called earthquake faultline supplied by de Vaux as having damaged the eastern cistern, seems to have been an invention, as another explanation for the data, supplied by our old

RE: orion-list Water, Water everywhere...

2002-06-23 Thread David C. Hindley
Ian H says: The conversation was about the limit of the sea level based on the location of Ein Feshka during the Qumran period. I can't see how hypothetical crevices, passes, caves, etc., have any bearing on the local topography so as to render irrelevant the altitude of Ein Feshka as a limiting

RE: orion-list Water, Water everywhere...

2002-06-23 Thread Dave Washburn
Ian H says: The conversation was about the limit of the sea level based on the location of Ein Feshka during the Qumran period. I can't see how hypothetical crevices, passes, caves, etc., have any bearing on the local topography so as to render irrelevant the altitude of Ein Feshka as a

RE: orion-list Water, Water everywhere...

2002-06-23 Thread David C. Hindley
Dave Washburn says: First, I think Ian is right to request some evidence of such a change. There should be a way to tell by something in the topography whether such alterations might have taken place, correct? Second, since it is specifically the Dead Sea that is being discussed, why not skip

Re: orion-list Water, Water everywhere...

2002-06-23 Thread Rochelle I. Altman
Dear Ian, Okay, time for a coffee break in any case... The cracked cistern --- Zavislock, an architect with experience in repairs after earthquake damage (who did reconstruction work at Qumran). S [snip] He sees that the cracking was done at the first

RE: orion-list Water, Water everywhere...

2002-06-23 Thread David C. Hindley
For what it is worth, while finding no good links to topographical maps of the Dead Sea region, it does appear that Rochelle is obtaining her information from the following book, or something very like it: _The Dead Sea: The Lake and Its Setting_, Edited by TINA M. NIEMI, University of Missouri,