[peirce-l] Re: What

2006-10-09 Thread Jim Piat
.Clark Goble wrote: I honestly don't recall Peirce addressing the problem of competing and contradictory beliefs. Does anyone know off the top of their head anything along those lines? The closest I can think of is the passage of 1908 to Lady Welby where he talks about the three

[peirce-l] Re: What

2006-10-09 Thread Claudio Guerri
List, I could not follow the last discussion on tenacity and related items in all details, since Iwas in Memphis and now in Pittsburgh and with no muchtime nor easy access to Internet. But I think (I only think) that Peirce maid his best efforts in the direction of Logic-Semiotic-Philosophy.

[peirce-l] Re: What

2006-10-09 Thread Jeff Kasser
Thanks for your response, Joe. I remain unconvinced; perhaps a look at the relevant pages of W3 will help me see things your way. I'll be traveling for the rest of this week, but will look into that upon my return. Here I'll just offer a quick gesture or two about how our disagreement looks