on Diamond's Guns, Germs Steel

2000-04-18 Thread Jim Devine
Barkley Rosser (once of pen-l, soon to return) forwards these comments on Jared Diamond's _Guns, Germs Steel_ Remarks on Diamond in light of Devine and DeLong reviews: I think the claim that _Germs, Guns, and Steel_ by Jared Diamond is the greatest work of genius in econ

Re: on Diamond's Guns, Germs Steel

2000-04-18 Thread Charles Brown
Jim Devine [EMAIL PROTECTED] 04/18/00 02:39PMBut, there is a big problem with Diamond's argument and it is Africa. O'Neill and others make it clear that Africa, the likely origin of humanity, has more diseases than anywhere else in the world and many of these came from contact