Re: Perl versus UNIX Korn Shell

2008-02-25 Thread Andrew Savige
Like Anthony Esposito in Nov 2003, I had a need recently to persuade some folks to use Perl rather than Unix shell and remembered this old thread. I've summarized my arguments at: http://www.perlmonks.org/?node_id=668481 Feedback welcome. Thanks, /-\ Get the name you always wanted

Re: Perl versus UNIX Korn Shell

2008-02-25 Thread Tim Maher
On Mon, Feb 25, 2008 at 12:57:41PM -0800, Andrew Savige wrote: Like Anthony Esposito in Nov 2003, I had a need recently to persuade some folks to use Perl rather than Unix shell and remembered this old thread. I've summarized my arguments at: http://www.perlmonks.org/?node_id=668481

Re: Perl versus UNIX Korn Shell

2003-11-08 Thread
In article [EMAIL PROTECTED], [EMAIL PROTECTED] (Anthony Esposito) writes: How would you convince someone that programming in Perl is better than using the UNIX Korn Shell? I need some 'intellectual ammo' to convince my colleagues that Perl is a better, more powerful language, to do our

Re: Perl versus UNIX Korn Shell

2003-11-07 Thread Michael R . Wolf
Tim Maher [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: [...] This means shell programmers have to learn other technologies to get any real work done, and for UNIX/Linux folks, the best choices are Perl, Awk, and then grep/sed/sort/find/tr/col/dd/m4, etc. Someone had mentioned that there is no CPAN for the

Re: Perl versus UNIX Korn Shell

2003-11-06 Thread Michael R . Wolf
Esposito, Anthony [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: How would you convince someone that programming in Perl is better than using the UNIX Korn Shell? I wouldn't. I use both. Here's one argument -- the titles of my reference books for each. Programming Perl, 3rd edition, Wall,

Re: Perl versus UNIX Korn Shell

2003-11-06 Thread Michael R . Wolf
Ben Okopnik [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: [...] As a small comparison, one of my students had a shell script that processed a pair of files, about 75MB each, by doing _something_ (I don't remember the exact details) that involved taking a line from file1 and doing something to every line in

Re: Perl versus UNIX Korn Shell

2003-11-06 Thread Steven Lembark
--On Wednesday, November 05, 2003 15:44:17 -0600 Jonathan Scott Duff [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: On Wed, Nov 05, 2003 at 04:19:44PM -0500, Esposito, Anthony wrote: How would you convince someone that programming in Perl is better than using the UNIX Korn Shell? I need some 'intellectual ammo' to

Re: Perl versus UNIX Korn Shell

2003-11-06 Thread Tim Maher
On Wed, Nov 05, 2003 at 04:19:44PM -0500, Esposito, Anthony wrote: How would you convince someone that programming in Perl is better than using the UNIX Korn Shell? I agreed with many of the comments others gave on this thread, regarding how each has its merits. To summarize a bit and add my

Re: Perl versus UNIX Korn Shell

2003-11-05 Thread Brad Lhotsky
Shell scripting is just that. Scripting. Its difficult to make reusable code and even more difficult to extend. Perl is a full featured programming language. It works wells with the UNIX Shell and is often used in place of scripting languages. I got my start converting shell scripts to perl

Re: Perl versus UNIX Korn Shell

2003-11-05 Thread Ben Okopnik
On Wed, Nov 05, 2003 at 04:19:44PM -0500, Esposito, Anthony wrote: How would you convince someone that programming in Perl is better than using the UNIX Korn Shell? I need some `intellectual ammo' to convince my colleagues that Perl is a better, more powerful language, to do our

Re: Perl versus UNIX Korn Shell

2003-11-05 Thread Jonathan Scott Duff
On Wed, Nov 05, 2003 at 04:19:44PM -0500, Esposito, Anthony wrote: How would you convince someone that programming in Perl is better than using the UNIX Korn Shell? I need some 'intellectual ammo' to convince my colleagues that Perl is a better, more powerful language, to do our scripting.

Re: Perl versus UNIX Korn Shell

2003-11-05 Thread Chris Benson
On Wed, Nov 05, 2003 at 04:19:44PM -0500, Esposito, Anthony wrote: How would you convince someone that programming in Perl is better than using the UNIX Korn Shell? I need some 'intellectual ammo' to convince my colleagues that Perl is a better, more powerful language, to do our

Re: Perl versus UNIX Korn Shell

2003-11-05 Thread Danny Faught
Esposito, Anthony wrote: How would you convince someone that programming in Perl is better than using the UNIX Korn Shell? I need some intellectual ammo to convince my colleagues that Perl is a better, more powerful language, to do our scripting. Any suggestions? J The shell doesn't do most

Re: Perl versus UNIX Korn Shell

2003-11-05 Thread Andrew Savige
Chris Benson wrote: If you do want ammo, my war-story is: I'm doing some Perl courses at IBM in the UK, Perl is *the* scripting language used for writing tests and product builds for MQ, the SSA disk group ... and the Java development group. Their main requirements are a common language