Re: [PHP-DOC] Notes system (again)

2003-11-21 Thread Mehdi Achour
Jared W wrote: [ ... ] Some good points here :) I'm leaning towards weaning the entire PHP documentation process away from the general php bugs system, as the two just don't seem to be the best of friends. This new notes system can be a big part of the new setup. Regards, Philip Have

Re: [PHP-DOC] Notes system (again)

2003-11-21 Thread Mehdi Achour
Gabor Hojtsy wrote: That was my original idea. Anyone can submit a bug report, fixing it should be left to whoever has CVS access to phpdoc. We can even use for the bug report originator the php-notes lists address, that way the other editors will know that someone did mark a particular entry as

RE: [PHP-DOC] Notes system (again)

2003-11-20 Thread jared w
Well, if someone has no CVS account then he will not be able to fix the docbug in the documentation CVS, so he can only mark it 'to be fixed in the toc' AKA 'docbugreport', so someone with a CVS account can fix it. If the note maintainer system would enable someone to move a

Re: [PHP-DOC] Notes system (again)

2003-11-20 Thread Gabor Hojtsy
That was my original idea. Anyone can submit a bug report, fixing it should be left to whoever has CVS access to phpdoc. We can even use for the bug report originator the php-notes lists address, that way the other editors will know that someone did mark a particular entry as such and does not

Re: [PHP-DOC] Notes system (again)

2003-11-19 Thread Gabor Hojtsy
The integration bit could be done as a documentation bug report, with the advantage that there will be a track record of the action/contents. Do you mean that user notes would be automatically turned into documentation bug reports if decided by a note admin? This sounds good to me :) Others will

Re: [PHP-DOC] Notes system (again)

2003-11-19 Thread Jesus M. Castagnetto
--- Gabor Hojtsy [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: The integration bit could be done as a documentation bug report, with the advantage that there will be a track record of the action/contents. Do you mean that user notes would be automatically turned into documentation bug reports if decided by

Re: [PHP-DOC] Notes system (again)

2003-11-19 Thread Philip Olson
Well, if someone has no CVS account then he will not be able to fix the docbug in the documentation CVS, so he can only mark it 'to be fixed in the toc' AKA 'docbugreport', so someone with a CVS account can fix it. If the note maintainer system would enable someone to move a

Re: [PHP-DOC] Notes system (again)

2003-11-18 Thread Allowee
On Tuesday 18 November 2003 00:35, Jesus M. Castagnetto wrote: --- Mehdi Achour [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hi ! It's been a while since the thread [1] wasn't discussed, so here we go again. After 3 months, here's the situation reviewed : 1) - Notes posted : We receive about 30

Re: [PHP-DOC] Notes system (again)

2003-11-18 Thread Gabor Hojtsy
The integration bit could be done as a documentation bug report, with the advantage that there will be a track record of the action/contents. Do you mean that user notes would be automatically turned into documentation bug reports if decided by a note admin? This sounds good to me :) Others will

Re: [PHP-DOC] Notes system (again)

2003-11-18 Thread Mehdi Achour
Gabor Hojtsy wrote: Submitter email The note Manual page Delete : trash Integrated Reject : bug support not our thing To be integrated Search the note database Seems to be fine with me. The URLs need to be shorter and more clear IMHO. It would

Re: [PHP-DOC] Notes system (again)

2003-11-18 Thread Mehdi Achour
Jesus M. Castagnetto wrote: --- Mehdi Achour [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hi ! It's been a while since the thread [1] wasn't discussed, so here we go again. After 3 months, here's the situation reviewed : 1) - Notes posted : We receive about 30 notes a day, most of them are : I - Asking for

Re: [PHP-DOC] Notes system (again)

2003-11-18 Thread Mehdi Achour
Allowee wrote: On Tuesday 18 November 2003 00:35, Jesus M. Castagnetto wrote: --- Mehdi Achour [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hi ! It's been a while since the thread [1] wasn't discussed, so here we go again. After 3 months, here's the situation reviewed : 1) - Notes posted : We receive about 30

Re: [PHP-DOC] Notes system (again)

2003-11-18 Thread Philip Olson
On Tue, 18 Nov 2003, Gabor Hojtsy wrote: The integration bit could be done as a documentation bug report, with the advantage that there will be a track record of the action/contents. Do you mean that user notes would be automatically turned into documentation bug reports if decided by

Re: [PHP-DOC] Notes system (again)

2003-11-17 Thread Jesus M. Castagnetto
--- Mehdi Achour [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hi ! It's been a while since the thread [1] wasn't discussed, so here we go again. After 3 months, here's the situation reviewed : 1) - Notes posted : We receive about 30 notes a day, most of them are : I - Asking for help II -

Re: [PHP-DOC] Notes system (again)

2003-11-16 Thread Derek Ford
Hmm, this seems to be a good idea to me. The more information gathered about these things the better. As per those who are too lazy for such a system; why are you on the phpdoc team in the first place? Mehdi Achour wrote: Hi ! It's been a while since the thread [1] wasn't discussed, so here

Re: [PHP-DOC] Notes system (again)

2003-11-16 Thread Gabor Hojtsy
Submitter email The note Manual page Delete : trash Integrated Reject : bug support not our thing To be integrated Search the note database Seems to be fine with me. The URLs need to be shorter and more clear IMHO. It would be nice to set up a

Re: [PHP-DOC] Notes system (again)

2003-11-16 Thread Mehdi Achour
Gabor Hojtsy wrote: Submitter email The note Manual page Delete : trash Integrated Reject : bug support not our thing To be integrated Search the note database Seems to be fine with me. The URLs need to be shorter and more clear IMHO. It