Re: [RDA-L] Some comments on the Final Report of the FRBR Working Group on Aggregates

2012-01-08 Thread Heidrun Wiesenmüller
Karen Coyle wrote: What type of entity would be part be? I'm thinking that there is no such entity as part but that a work can be a is part of another work. Taking into account that the work is a single entity that may be related to any number of expression/manifestations it cannot be

Re: [RDA-L] Some comments on the Final Report of the FRBR Working Group on Aggregates

2012-01-08 Thread Heidrun Wiesenmüller
Here are some more issues with the model of the Working Group, now centering on the concept of an aggregating expression. The more I think about this, the less I understand what this entity is supposed to be in the first place, and what might be the point of having it at all. In the main body

Re: [RDA-L] Some comments on the Final Report of the FRBR Working Group on Aggregates

2012-01-08 Thread J. McRee Elrod
In article 4f093f5d.4070...@hdm-stuttgart.de, you wrote: Actually, the thing Mac and I disagree about (but haven't had time to go into more deeply yet) is the question of main entry as such. Main entry under creator seems a tradition worth keeping: -in order to maintain consistency with

Re: [RDA-L] Some comments on the Final Report of the FRBR Working Group on Aggregates

2012-01-08 Thread Brenndorfer, Thomas
From: Resource Description and Access / Resource Description and Access [RDA-L@LISTSERV.LAC-BAC.GC.CA] On Behalf Of J. McRee Elrod [m...@slc.bc.ca] Sent: January-08-12 11:53 AM To: RDA-L@LISTSERV.LAC-BAC.GC.CA Subject: Re: [RDA-L] Some comments on the

Re: [RDA-L] Some comments on the Final Report of the FRBR Working Group on Aggregates

2012-01-08 Thread J. McRee Elrod
Thomas said: A collection of short stories would get the 650 heading, Short stories ... In our shop, a collection of short stories would have that heading in a 655; only criticism of short stories would have that heading in 650. Having it in 650 would exclude it from a genre index. Many

Re: [RDA-L] Some comments on the Final Report of the FRBR Working Group on Aggregates

2012-01-08 Thread Bernhard Eversberg
08.01.2012 15:24, Heidrun Wiesenmüller: Here are some more issues with the model of the Working Group, now centering on the concept of an aggregating expression. The more I think about this, the less I understand what this entity is supposed to be in the first place, and what might be the point