Thomas Brenndorfer said:
In several early chapters in RDA there is only a thin blue line separating the movement
from manifestation attributes to item attributes, and from work attributes to expression
attributes. For an example of a boundary, see the blue separator Other Identifying
26.11.2012 12:17, James Weinheimer:
Let's face it: the FRBR structure is bizarre and difficult even for
trained catalogers to grasp.
... and to apply consistently end efficiently.
The FRBR user tasks are from an earlier time, and in any case, the
public hasn't been able to do them since
snip
Anyway, I really don't like this speculating around in this list
with no input from those who should know more and might easily resolve
errors in our wild guesses. Can this be called a discussion list? It is
rather another Speakers' Corner, inconsequential at the end of the day.
Not the first
24.11.2012 11:37, Heidrun Wiesenmüller:
... BIBFRAME simply _must_ be able to
model RDA data in the necessary granularity and specificity.
That should indeed go without saying. And besides, it ought to be
integrated with RDA documentation as well, so as to enable linking
in both directions.
One of the first things I noticed was the example that showed Tunnel books as
a subject. While this may reflect (incorrect) MARC 21 coding as 650, the resource/work
being described is clearly not ABOUT tunnel books, it IS a tunnel book. The correct MARC
coding of course would be either 655
To: RDA-L@LISTSERV.LAC-BAC.GC.CA
Subject: Re: [RDA-L] BIBFRAME model document announced
Posted to Bibframe:
http://www.loc.gov/marc/transition/pdf/marcld-report-11-21-2012.pdf
Creative Work - a resource reflecting a conceptual essence of the
cataloging item.
Instance - a resource reflecting
@LISTSERV.LAC-BAC.GC.CA
Subject: Re: [RDA-L] BIBFRAME model document announced
This is indeed rather unsettling.
Funnily enough, they even take the FRBR report (1997 text, in the English
version) as their example to show what BIBFRAME might look like (p. 16ff).
But one wonders whether
7 matches
Mail list logo
