Re: Cupertino case dismissed

2005-08-16 Thread Rick Duncan
Here is the ADF take on the settlement: CUPERTINO, Calif. - Attorneys with the Alliance Defense Fund and the Cupertino Union School District filed a settlement agreement today in the lawsuit Williams v. Vidmar. "We are pleased that this matter has been resolved to the satisfaction of all

Re: !RE: FW: Feature films on church and state

2005-08-16 Thread Rick Duncan
Luther, starring Joseph Fiennes, is yet another great film on Church and State. We watched it this weekend at our house, and I heartily recommend it. Cheers, Rick DuncanRick Duncan Welpton Professor of Law University of Nebraska College of Law Lincoln, NE 68583-0902"When the Round Table is broken

Re: Cupertino case dismissed

2005-08-16 Thread Steven Jamar
spin spin spin -- on both sidesthe materials used by the teacher included many things that had not business being therethe school district restates its policy and has a case which adds some clarity to its bounds (the teacher at issue was out of bounds by a lot)and now we spin it on this listthe

Re: Cupertino case dismissed

2005-08-16 Thread Ed Brayton
Rick Duncan wrote: Here is the ADF take on the settlement: CUPERTINO, Calif. - Attorneys with the Alliance Defense Fund and the Cupertino Union School District filed a settlement agreement today in the lawsuit Williams v. Vidmar. "We are pleased that this matter has been

Re: Cupertino case dismissed

2005-08-16 Thread A.E. Brownstein
I'm not at all as confident as Rick is that It is always good to stand up for the academic freedom of teachers, particularly when they are presenting one-sided religious or political programs in their classrooms and refuse to accept the curricular guidelines of their school. Perhaps Rick is

Re: Cupertino case dismissed

2005-08-16 Thread Ed Brayton
A.E. Brownstein wrote: I'm not at all as confident as Rick is that It is always good to stand up for the academic freedom of teachers, particularly when they are presenting one-sided religious or political programs in their classrooms and refuse to accept the curricular guidelines of their

Re: Cupertino case dismissed

2005-08-16 Thread Rick Duncan
I haven't followed this case very carefully either, Alan. AndI don't know if I'm "breaking ranks" with conservative judges orwhether theyare breaking ranks with me.I am much more of a libertarian than a conservative anyway. But, of course, government schools and their monopoly over

RE: Cupertino case dismissed

2005-08-16 Thread Sanford Levinson
I am reading an absolutely terrific manuscript by Columbia historian Richard Bushman, a biography of Joseph Smith, which is extremely illuminating on LDS theology. (Not the least interesting feature of the manuscript is Bushman's threading the needle with regard to the ontological status of

Re: Court's Kelo Decision Puts Religious Property at Risk

2005-08-16 Thread Hamilton02
When it was decided, which is a while ago, the Cottonwood case was reportedon everywhere. There was no "liberal press cover up." Marci In a message dated 8/16/2005 11:26:53 A.M. Eastern Standard Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Interesting article. This kind of thing is exactly what I

Re: Cupertino case dismissed

2005-08-16 Thread Ed Darrell
I reviewed the materials, and as a Social Studies teacher I found them inadequate, inaccurate, and impermissibly biased. I don't think any public interest group does anyone a favor when they defend teaching substandard and inaccurate material. Mr. Brayton's analysis is probably close to the mark:

Re: Court's Kelo Decision Puts Religious Property at Risk

2005-08-16 Thread Brad M Pardee
Somebody else has also told me that it was in the news at the time. I try to stay aware of these cases in the news, and I hadn't heard anything, unlike Employment Division Vs. Smith, Boerne Vs. Flores, and cases like that. That being the case, if you tell me it was in the news, I'll take your

Re: Massachusetts proposals to force church disclosures

2005-08-16 Thread Paul Finkelman
My understanding is that there is a large Catholic majority in the Mass. legislature; if so, then are you suggesing that thte legislture is anti-Catholic? Vance R. Koven wrote: I'm a bit surprised that nobody here has brought up the recent initiatives of the Massachusetts legislature to