RE: [scots-l] Was Burns a racist?

2001-01-29 Thread jwa
oh, ok. the part where he quoted from my post had me confused. bob Perhaps this unnatural leaping is a clue that Ian was not responding to your message, but to things he has heard elsewhere? Aye, tis at tha! Posted to Scots-L - The Traditional Scottish Music Culture List - To

Re: [scots-l] Was Burns a racist?

2001-01-29 Thread Toby Rider
jwa wrote: oh, ok. the part where he quoted from my post had me confused. bob It's very easy to get confused as to who said what when there is a thread with lot's of posts and quoting like this one on Burns. Posted to Scots-L - The Traditional Scottish Music Culture List - To

RE: [scots-l] Was Burns a racist?

2001-01-23 Thread jwa
the above. bob -Original Message- From: Ian Adkins [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] Sent: Monday, January 22, 2001 8:52 PM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: [scots-l] Was Burns a racist? Whit're ye oan aboot? A wisna flamin oniebodie. Awa an get yer paranoid gland luikt at, A

RE: [scots-l] Was Burns a racist?

2001-01-22 Thread jwa
Networks, Limited http://www.blackmill.net - Original Message - From: jwa [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Thursday, January 18, 2001 4:44 PM Subject: RE: [scots-l] Was Burns a racist? -Original Message

Re: [scots-l] Was Burns a racist?

2001-01-18 Thread Anselm Lingnau
In article [EMAIL PROTECTED], Derek Hoy [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I played in a show several years ago about his life (sponsored by the Post Office :) It is crying out to be turned into a screenplay. Incidentally, there is a Scottish country dance called Indian Peter's Reel, devised by the

Re: [scots-l] Was Burns a racist?

2001-01-18 Thread Abby Sale
On Tue, 16 Jan 2001 22:37:15 +, David Kilpatrick wrote: Buchan's note implies that it might well have involved ANY children, of ANY families. Given the strong family ties present in any town, even as big as Aberdeen, and the propensity of families for direct revenge it seems unlikely that

Re: [scots-l] Was Burns a racist?

2001-01-17 Thread Jack Campin
Was Burns a racist? Just before his Kilmarnock edition came out - his first collection of poems - he hoped that the money from it would be enough to start a new life in Jamaica as a 'Negro-driver', a slave owner. Was it a case of, 'A man's a man for a that - exept negroes'? Did he change his

Re: [scots-l] Was Burns a racist?

2001-01-17 Thread David Kilpatrick
Jack Campin wrote: Peter Williamson, aka "Indian Peter", who went on to set up a postal service and published the first postal directory of Edinburgh. See Kay's "Edinburgh Portraits", or pretty much any book about 18th century Edinburgh, he was a very well-known character. He turned into

Re: [scots-l] Was Burns a racist?

2001-01-17 Thread Derek Hoy
David asked: Do I take it, basically, that Peter Buchan's notes to his Ballads in 1828 are as badly researched as they are badly written? Williamson's story, and Buchan's notes, bear hallmarks of exaggeration and maybe the magistrates of Aberdeen were quite right to burn his book. Peter

Re: [scots-l] Was Burns a racist?

2001-01-17 Thread Clarsaich
In a message dated 1/16/01 3:09:23 PM Eastern Standard Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: In Maryland, at least, they are beautifully indexed, so you're not hunting needles in haystacks looking for reference to your folks. I'm in Maryland, but my Grandfather lived most of his life in

Re: [scots-l] Was Burns a racist?

2001-01-17 Thread Susan Tichy
Are you really comparing being a Negro-driver to working for a brokerage firm? That latter might be closer to being an exiseman. But a slave owner? OK, maybe you were only kidding... Rob I was kidding... though as I think about it now it's not entirely off-base, since in the context of

Re: [scots-l] Was Burns a racist?

2001-01-16 Thread Rob MacKillop
Was the slave ship anything to do with negroes? All the comments about Gaelic slaves are really interesting and I hope to read more about them on this List. Keep them coming. However, I orginally asked about Burns the 'Negro-driver' - no Gaels mentioned there, nor in his 'Slaves Lament' which

Re: [scots-l] Was Burns a racist?

2001-01-16 Thread Clarsaich
In a message dated 1/16/01 4:28:39 AM Eastern Standard Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: He may have thought, in an idealised moment, that slavery was wrong, but he obviously was prepared to accept it and engage himself in its practices had his poems failed to sell. Reminds one of Thomas

Re: [scots-l] Was Burns a racist?

2001-01-16 Thread David Kilpatrick
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: whether they decided to stay or go home once freed Now this is a piece of the puzzle we had lost! My Grandfather's grandparents must have (might have?) gone back to Scotland. 'cause the thing that has confused me is how his grandparents were here, yet he was

Re: [scots-l] Was Burns a racist?

2001-01-16 Thread Rob MacKillop
Susan Tichy wrote: ...or thought in a despairing moment that he would have to do whatever offered itself... much as a musician might contemplate a brokerage firm on a really, really bad day. Are you really comparing being a Negro-driver to working for a brokerage firm? That latter might be

Re: [scots-l] Was Burns a racist?

2001-01-15 Thread Clarsaich
[EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Gaelic speaking Scottish slaves, children rounded up by the burgesses of the port towns and shipped to the Americas for cash. This is really interesting to me. My grandfather Ogilvie always told me his grandparents came to this country as indentured servants or

Re: [scots-l] Was Burns a racist?

2001-01-15 Thread David Kilpatrick
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Gaelic speaking Scottish slaves, children rounded up by the burgesses of the port towns and shipped to the Americas for cash. This is really interesting to me. My grandfather Ogilvie always told me his grandparents came to this

Re: [scots-l] Was Burns a racist?

2001-01-15 Thread Susan Tichy
Cynthia wrote: This is really interesting to me. My grandfather Ogilvie always told me his grandparents came to this country as indentured servants or sharecroppers, and then he'd snort and say, "which meant SLAVERY!" The deal,as he told it, was that eventually you could purchase yourself,