Re: Missing Option AuthRequiredForAllIPs

2004-07-28 Thread Danny Angus
The result? The connection issued by ASSP comes from 127.0.0.1 which is an authorized address, for obvious reasons. As a consequences james answer to isAuthorized() is Yes, which causes it not to display the 250 auth login message and therefore causes thunderbird not to use auth. I though

Re: Missing Option AuthRequiredForAllIPs

2004-07-28 Thread Vincenzo Gianferrari Pini
Danny Angus wrote: The result? The connection issued by ASSP comes from 127.0.0.1 which is an authorized address, for obvious reasons. As a consequences james answer to isAuthorized() is Yes, which causes it not to display the 250 auth login message and therefore causes thunderbird not to use

Re: Missing Option AuthRequiredForAllIPs

2004-07-28 Thread Jacques Lema
Yes, of course I actually fixed the problem for me by commenting this line since this exact server doesn't really need to allow localhost to send mail. However I think it would be a nice addition to have an option to force always showing the AUTH capability. I am not familiar with james source

Re: Missing Option AuthRequiredForAllIPs

2004-07-28 Thread Vincenzo Gianferrari Pini
But wouldn't it be totally equivalent to commenting out such option? Vincenzo Jacques Lema wrote: Yes, of course I actually fixed the problem for me by commenting this line since this exact server doesn't really need to allow localhost to send mail. However I think it would be a nice addition to

Re: Missing Option AuthRequiredForAllIPs

2004-07-28 Thread Jacques Lema
No it wouldn't. Imagine I would like to send mail from localhost without authentication? I just can't. At this point I have to chose between authentication working through a local proxy or allowing localhost to send mail. Vincenzo Gianferrari Pini wrote: But wouldn't it be totally equivalent

Re: Missing Option AuthRequiredForAllIPs

2004-07-28 Thread Danny Angus
At this point I have to chose between authentication working through a local proxy or allowing localhost to send mail. You asked for authentication to be required for localhost, you can't ask for it not to be required at the same time! d.

Re: Missing Option AuthRequiredForAllIPs

2004-07-28 Thread Jacques Lema
Let me explain :-) I don't want to _require_ authentication. I want it to be a possibility. What I would like is: a) be able to send a mail from localhost without authentication b) be able to send a mail from localhost (precisely from a spam-filtering proxy such as ASSP) _with_ authentication.

Re: Missing Option AuthRequiredForAllIPs

2004-07-28 Thread Danny Angus
What I would like is: a) be able to send a mail from localhost without authentication b) be able to send a mail from localhost (precisely from a spam-filtering proxy such as ASSP) _with_ authentication. As I understood it advertising AUTH supported is equivalet to requiring auth, are you