Re: t-and-f: water vs coke

2001-03-01 Thread Shawn Devereaux
Wasn't a distance runner a few years back almost suspended for too high of levels of caffiene? [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Netters Ed wrote: That said, many ultrarunners (even some of the good ones) swear by defizzed coke during a race of 50 miles or longer. It seems clear that both the

Re: t-and-f: water vs coke

2001-03-01 Thread Kurt Bray
Anne Marie Lauck drank coke in the 2000 marathon trials and had a major stomach problem during the race. Ed Too bad she didn't drink 5 glasses of water instead. She could have made the Olympic team and at the same time cut her risk of getting breast cancer by 79%! Kurt Bray

Re: t-and-f: water vs coke

2001-03-01 Thread Dan Kaplan
--- Shawn Devereaux [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Wasn't a distance runner a few years back almost suspended for too high of levels of caffiene? That same RRN article I mentioned also stated that the amount of caffeine necessary to place you above the legal limit is actually detrimental to

Re: t-and-f: water vs coke

2001-03-01 Thread Oleg
Yes and this runner's name was Daniel Komen. Oleg Wasn't a distance runner a few years back almost suspended for too high of levels of caffiene? [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Netters Ed wrote: That said, many ultrarunners (even some of the good ones) swear by defizzed coke during

Re: t-and-f: water vs coke

2001-03-01 Thread alan tobin
: Ed Dana Parrot [EMAIL PROTECTED] Reply-To: Ed Dana Parrot [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: t-and-f: water vs coke Date: Wed, 28 Feb 2001 21:16:59 -0800 dan wrote: In all seriousness, Owen Anderson's Running Research News published the results of a study around '94 or '95

t-and-f: water vs coke

2001-02-28 Thread Philip Weishaar
A friend sent me the following info. How much of this would you physiologist types consider to be true, especially about dehydration? "We all know that water is important but I've never seen it written down like this before." WATER - 75% of Americans are chronically dehydrated. (Likely

Re: t-and-f: water vs coke

2001-02-28 Thread Elliott Oti
I think the list is a mixture of facts, facts presented misleadingly, and outright falsehoods. The tone is somewhat sensational. For instance "a mere 2% drop in body water" is 2-3 lb of water; that's a lot of sweat. "Chronic dehydration" is not defined. Nor is "mild dehydration". The connection

Re: t-and-f: water vs coke

2001-02-28 Thread Kurt Bray
Looks to me like it has the makings of an internet hoax -- one of those scare-tactic e-mails that blends facts with lies in support of some agenda and then circulates endlessly on the net. Often these forms of mischief are targeted to damage some company. Notice in this one that they are

Re: t-and-f: water vs coke

2001-02-28 Thread philip_ponebshek
Phil Weishaar asked; A friend sent me the following info. How much of this would you physiologist types consider to be true, especially about dehydration? A mere 2% drop in body water can trigger fuzzy short-term memory, trouble with basic math, and difficulty focusing on the computer

Re: t-and-f: water vs coke

2001-02-28 Thread Ed Dana Parrot
A friend sent me the following info. How much of this would you physiologist types consider to be true, especially about dehydration? I can't speak for the observations about Coca Cola, although I know it can dissolve a lollipop in about ten minutes! From what I have heard and read, the stuff

Re: t-and-f: water vs coke

2001-02-28 Thread alan tobin
I think that it's pretty obvious that water is good for you and coke is bad for you when it comes to any sort of athletic performance. I drink my fair share of carbonated drinks so I try to drink a little more water at night to compensate for the dehydration. In my experience the caffeine in

RE: t-and-f: water vs coke

2001-02-28 Thread malmo
Never trust a man who relies on 'suhtisticks'. However, I usually do not trust actual percentages unless someone either cites the study or is extremely detailed in his discussion. For instance, drinking 5 glasses of water daily supposedly decreases the risk of breast cancer by 79%.

Re: t-and-f: water vs coke

2001-02-28 Thread GHTFNedit
In a message dated Wed, 28 Feb 2001 9:44:52 PM Eastern Standard Time, "Kurt Bray" [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: As I recall, Frank Shorter drank defizzed Coke during his gold medal run in '72. He must have served as Brian Oldfield's role model. At the TFN banquet in Munich (with unlimited

Re: t-and-f: water vs coke

2001-02-28 Thread Dan Kaplan
That said, many ultrarunners (even some of the good ones) swear by defizzed coke As I recall, Frank Shorter drank defizzed Coke Defizzed? What happened to good old "flat?" In all seriousness, Owen Anderson's Running Research News published the results of a study around '94 or '95 saying

Re: t-and-f: water vs coke

2001-02-28 Thread Ed Prytherch
Anne Marie Lauck drank coke in the 2000 marathon trials and had a major stomach problem during the race. Ed. As I recall, Frank Shorter drank defizzed Coke during his gold medal run in '72. Kurt Bray _ Get your FREE download

Re: t-and-f: water vs coke

2001-02-28 Thread philip_ponebshek
Jim Gerwick related: A friend of mine returned from a visit to South Africa, and she said Coke is THE drink of choice among runners there - she almost puked the first time she drank it though. Upon reading this, I'm immediately reminded of the scene in Biko where Steven rips the top off a

Re: t-and-f: water vs coke

2001-02-28 Thread Ed Dana Parrot
dan wrote: In all seriousness, Owen Anderson's Running Research News published the results of a study around '94 or '95 saying that flat Coke mixed with water could be very beneficial for events in the range of 1500m to 10k or so. I think caffeine was the major player. Caffeine, of course,

Re: t-and-f: water vs coke

2001-02-28 Thread mmrohl
Netters Ed wrote: That said, many ultrarunners (even some of the good ones) swear by defizzed coke during a race of 50 miles or longer. It seems clear that both the sugar and the caffeine could be helpful, Having done those 4 hour 50ks myself nothing works better then defizzed coke