Re: [Talk-GB] Potlatch Integrity button.

2009-07-19 Thread WessexMario
Chris Andrew wrote: Hi, all. Some time ago, I realised from this list that it is possible to get an overlay on OSM of mapping errors, such as roads that don't join, bad tags etc. I can never remember how to turn this on. Would it be possible for Potlatch to have an on/off button for this

[Talk-GB] Estimating coverage

2009-07-19 Thread Peter Reed
There have been a number of attempts to estimate the level of UK coverage, of varying levels of sophistication, but I've not seen any that compare the length of roads mapped against actual road lengths. The Department for Transport publishes statistics on actual road lengths by local

[Talk-GB] Unsubscribe

2009-07-19 Thread Sarah McCulloch
routing for projects such as Navit and OpenSatNav. What does anyone think? Chris (chris_debian) -- next part -- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-gb/attachments/20090719/4c4e2acc/attachment-0001.htm

Re: [Talk-GB] Unsubscribe

2009-07-19 Thread Chris Andrew
and OpenSatNav. What does anyone think? Chris (chris_debian) -- next part -- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-gb/attachments/20090719/4c4e2acc/attachment-0001.htm -- Message: 3 Date

[Talk-GB] Estimating coverage

2009-07-19 Thread Richard Bullock
Of the authorities I have managed to measure, the following all show more road mapped than the DfT believes exists: There could be a number of reasons for this; 1.Our boundaries are plotted from old parish boundaries on NPE typically. I had to move the Trafford/Manchester boundary in a

Re: [Talk-GB] Estimating coverage

2009-07-19 Thread Chris Hill
Peter Reed wrote: Of the authorities I have managed to measure, the following all show more road mapped than the DfT believes exists: Having mapped every road in Hull (Kingston-upon-Hull since today is a Sunday), some are fairly new and may not appear on the DfT figures.

Re: [Talk-GB] Estimating coverage

2009-07-19 Thread Peter Miller
On 19 Jul 2009, at 11:54, Chris Hill wrote: Peter Reed wrote: Of the authorities I have managed to measure, the following all show more road mapped than the DfT believes exists: Having mapped every road in Hull (Kingston-upon-Hull since today is a Sunday), some are fairly new and may

Re: [Talk-GB] Estimating coverage

2009-07-19 Thread Frederik Ramm
Hi, Peter Miller wrote: There is a relation for 'London Boroughs'. I wondered if we should produced one for 'Regions of England', and 'ceremonial counties of England' and add the appropriate relations to them. Generally, relations that just serve the purpose of collecting things are

Re: [Talk-GB] Estimating coverage

2009-07-19 Thread Peter Reed
On the problems with Hampshire - my only related experience is that I had problems with POSTGIS unable to process a number of admin boundaries, because they are plotted with loops in the boundary. I.e. the boundary crosses over itself. This mostly happened where the coast had been added to the

Re: [Talk-GB] Estimating coverage

2009-07-19 Thread Chris Hill
Frederik Ramm wrote: Interestingly I joined this list a while ago because I had got my hands on some admin boundary data for England and wanted to know if it was any good (the answer was no). I then forgot to unsubscribe. I'm still planning to extend the Geofabrik excerpts to cover all

Re: [Talk-GB] Estimating coverage

2009-07-19 Thread Peter Reed
FWIW I've now updated http://www.reedhome.org.uk/Documents/LGboundaries.csv to include a list of local authorities in Scotland, Wales and N. Ireland. ___ Talk-GB mailing list Talk-GB@openstreetmap.org

Re: [Talk-GB] Estimating coverage

2009-07-19 Thread Richard Bullock
The way I have handled dual carriageways (and motorways) is to assume that both carriageways are plotted separately on OSM. So the figure that results should be twice the length estimated by DfT. However, for primary roads, DfT themselves show the total length of primary road, and the

Re: [Talk-GB] Estimating coverage

2009-07-19 Thread Thomas Wood
2009/7/19 Frederik Ramm frede...@remote.org: Hi, Peter Miller wrote: There is a relation for 'London Boroughs'. I wondered if we should produced one for 'Regions of England', and 'ceremonial counties of England' and add the appropriate relations to them. Generally, relations that just

Re: [Talk-GB] Estimating coverage

2009-07-19 Thread Richard Bullock
Oh just a thought, does the calculations include toll roads? Do the DfT monitor these in their figures? (M6 toll, Severn Bridge etc.) Yes they do. It's in the notes on the DfT website that private toll roads which form part of major routes are included, but private minor roads are not.