Re: [DISCUSS] Geronimo-Tuscany integration(Sending to both lists)

2007-07-30 Thread Vamsavardhana Reddy
Sent: Friday, July 06, 2007 2:42 PM Subject: Re: [DISCUSS] Geronimo-Tuscany integration(Sending to both lists) Hi Simon, Comments inline. On 7/5/07, Simon Laws [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hi Manu more comments in line On 7/4/07, Manu George [EMAIL

Re: [DISCUSS] Geronimo-Tuscany integration(Sending to both lists)

2007-07-26 Thread Vamsavardhana Reddy
: Friday, July 06, 2007 2:42 PM Subject: Re: [DISCUSS] Geronimo-Tuscany integration(Sending to both lists) Hi Simon, Comments inline. On 7/5/07, Simon Laws [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hi Manu more comments in line On 7/4/07, Manu George [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote

Re: [DISCUSS] Geronimo-Tuscany integration(Sending to both lists)

2007-07-08 Thread Simon Laws
Hi Manu, I'm away this week but here are a few more thoughts for now. On 7/6/07, Manu George [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hi Simon, Comments inline. On 7/5/07, Simon Laws [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hi Manu more comments in line On 7/4/07, Manu George [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Re: [DISCUSS] Geronimo-Tuscany integration(Sending to both lists)

2007-07-06 Thread Manu George
Hi Simon, Comments inline. On 7/5/07, Simon Laws [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hi Manu more comments in line On 7/4/07, Manu George [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hi Simon, In one of the previous mails Sebastien proposed two ways of how the SCADomain should

Re: [DISCUSS] Geronimo-Tuscany integration(Sending to both lists)

2007-07-06 Thread Raymond Feng
@ws.apache.org Sent: Friday, July 06, 2007 2:42 PM Subject: Re: [DISCUSS] Geronimo-Tuscany integration(Sending to both lists) Hi Simon, Comments inline. On 7/5/07, Simon Laws [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hi Manu more comments in line On 7/4/07, Manu George [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hi

Re: [DISCUSS] Geronimo-Tuscany integration(Sending to both lists)

2007-07-06 Thread Luciano Resende
Comments in-line... On 7/6/07, Manu George [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hi Jacek, Comments inline On 7/5/07, Jacek Laskowski [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: On 7/4/07, Manu George [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Yes you are right. But if you see the Tuscany samples it supports SCA modules that don't have

Re: [DISCUSS] Geronimo-Tuscany integration(Sending to both lists)

2007-07-05 Thread Simon Laws
Hi Manu more comments in line On 7/4/07, Manu George [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hi Simon, In one of the previous mails Sebastien proposed two ways of how the SCADomain should exist in geronimo (a) one instance of SCADomain per component running on the server, loaded with a

Re: [DISCUSS] Geronimo-Tuscany integration(Sending to both lists)

2007-07-05 Thread Luciano Resende
Reddy wrote: Hi, Myself and Manu have done some work (a small PoC) on Geronimo Tuscany integration. As a first step, we have created a plugin for Geronimo that will let the user to deploy standalone tuscany modules into Geronimo and use the deployed services by looking up in JNDI. I

Re: [DISCUSS] Geronimo-Tuscany integration(Sending to both lists)

2007-07-04 Thread Manu George
Hi Jacek, Glad that you could join this discussion. Welcome :). We need more participants like you to join this dicussion to come out with the best approach. I have added my comments inline on my understanding on why we should be doing this. This is actually based on the JEE SCA

Re: [DISCUSS] Geronimo-Tuscany integration(Sending to both lists)

2007-07-04 Thread Manu George
7:53 AM Subject: Re: [DISCUSS] Geronimo-Tuscany integration(Sending to both lists) Hi , From Paul's mail I guess a Geronimo plugin would be the way forward. I am going to list down a few more questions on the scenarios that Sebastien has explained. The scenarios are given first

Re: [DISCUSS] Geronimo-Tuscany integration(Sending to both lists)

2007-07-04 Thread Manu George
Hi Simon, In one of the previous mails Sebastien proposed two ways of how the SCADomain should exist in geronimo (a) one instance of SCADomain per component running on the server, loaded with a subset of the distributed SCA domain composite representing that component and enough

Re: [DISCUSS] Geronimo-Tuscany integration(Sending to both lists)

2007-07-04 Thread Manu George
Hi Jacek, The spec also says in 1.10.2.2. The contribution optionally contains a document that declares runnable composites, exported definitions and imported definitions. The document is found at the path of META-INF/sca-contribution.xml relative to the root of the contribution.I

Re: [DISCUSS] Geronimo-Tuscany integration(Sending to both lists)

2007-07-03 Thread Manu George
Hi , From Paul's mail I guess a Geronimo plugin would be the way forward. I am going to list down a few more questions on the scenarios that Sebastien has explained. The scenarios are given first and then my understanding, approach and issues. I would be just listing two of the

Re: [DISCUSS] Geronimo-Tuscany integration(Sending to both lists)

2007-07-03 Thread Raymond Feng
Hi, Please see my comments inline. Thanks, Raymond - Original Message - From: Manu George [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Cc: tuscany-dev@ws.apache.org Sent: Tuesday, July 03, 2007 7:53 AM Subject: Re: [DISCUSS] Geronimo-Tuscany integration(Sending to both lists) Hi

Re: [DISCUSS] Geronimo-Tuscany integration(Sending to both lists)

2007-07-03 Thread Simon Laws
-Tuscany integration(Sending to both lists) Hi , From Paul's mail I guess a Geronimo plugin would be the way forward. I am going to list down a few more questions on the scenarios that Sebastien has explained. The scenarios are given first and then my understanding, approach

Re: Geronimo/Tuscany integration

2007-06-29 Thread Manu George
Hi Jean-Sebastien, Thank you for the very detailed responses and links. I am still in the process of going through the SCA specs. With my current understanding I have put in responses inline On 6/27/07, Jean-Sebastien Delfino [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Raymond is away for one

Re: [DISCUSS] Geronimo-Tuscany integration(Sending to both lists)

2007-06-29 Thread Manu George
Hi Jean-Sebastien, I have put the comments inline. Vamsavardhana Reddy wrote: Hi, Myself and Manu have done some work (a small PoC) on Geronimo Tuscany integration. As a first step, we have created a plugin for Geronimo that will let the user to deploy standalone tuscany modules

[DISCUSS] Geronimo-Tuscany integration

2007-06-26 Thread Vamsavardhana Reddy
Hi, Myself and Manu have done some work (a small PoC) on Geronimo Tuscany integration. As a first step, we have created a plugin for Geronimo that will let the user to deploy standalone tuscany modules into Geronimo and use the deployed services by looking up in JNDI. I have put the code

Re: Geronimo/Tuscany integration

2007-06-26 Thread Jean-Sebastien Delfino
Raymond is away for one more week, so I'll try to answer some of these questions. Manu George wrote: Hi Raymond/Jay, I would like to join this effort. I would like to discuss what is expected of the deep integration. I will just list down my understanding of both the current and

Re: [DISCUSS] Geronimo-Tuscany integration

2007-06-26 Thread Jean-Sebastien Delfino
Comments inline. Vamsavardhana Reddy wrote: Hi, Myself and Manu have done some work (a small PoC) on Geronimo Tuscany integration. As a first step, we have created a plugin for Geronimo that will let the user to deploy standalone tuscany modules into Geronimo and use the deployed services

Re: Geronimo/Tuscany integration

2007-06-13 Thread Vamsavardhana Reddy
Hi, Myself and Manu have been working on the integration thing. As a first step, we have created a plugin for Geronimo that will let the user to deploy standalone tuscany modules into Geronimo and use the deployed services by looking up in JNDI. I have put the code in Geronimo Sandbox at

Re: Geronimo/Tuscany integration

2007-05-10 Thread Manu George
Hi Raymond/Jay, I would like to join this effort. I would like to discuss what is expected of the deep integration. I will just list down my understanding of both the current and proposed integrations Understanding of the Current Integration 1) TuscanyContextListener creates an SCA domain

Geronimo/Tuscany integration

2007-04-25 Thread Raymond Feng
Hi, Geronimo community. As you may know, Tuscany is an Apache project under incubation to provide an open source SOA infrastructure. For more information, you can visit http://cwiki.apache.org/TUSCANY/. Tuscany implements the SCA specification (http://www.osoa.org) and allows you to develop