RE: [WSG] Absolute positioning vs floats

2004-08-26 Thread Anura . Samara
Thanks everyone for your thoughts on positioning vs float... except of course that opinion is divided! As usual, its a matter of finding the best fit for what I want to achieve. I think I might do a new version of the site using floats over the weekend, just to see if it makes a difference. My

Re: [WSG] Absolute positioning vs floats

2004-08-25 Thread Justin French
Anura, I noticed someone made the comment that the preferred floats to absolute positioning. I have just created a new design using absolute positioning. It 'seems' to work across IE, Mozilla, Opera and latest Netscape (I'm trying to forget about NS4.7). But what is the consensus amongst my

Re: [WSG] Absolute positioning vs floats

2004-08-25 Thread Patrick H. Lauke
When done properly, with due care for which parent container it uses, absolute positioning yields a lot more robust results, imho. It would be dangerous to simply dismiss absolute positioning in favour of floats. You've just got to be careful in how you position things, to avoid potential

RE: [WSG] Absolute positioning vs floats

2004-08-25 Thread Mike Foskett
Hi Anura, Personally, I go with floats every time. Absolute positioning relies on the display size too much. It also allows coders to apply fixes to the document flow. Have you considered the documents appearance on a 160px wide PDA? How about a Braille reader? mike 2k:)2 marqueeblink

Re: [WSG] Absolute positioning vs floats

2004-08-25 Thread Kay Smoljak
On Wed, 25 Aug 2004 09:49:52 +0100, Mike Foskett [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Personally, I go with floats every time. Absolute positioning relies on the display size too much. I try to mix it up a bit - there's lots of browser bugs with floats (think Mac IE5). Absolute positioning is fantastic for

Re: [WSG] Absolute positioning vs floats

2004-08-25 Thread Nick Gleitzman
On Wednesday, Aug 25, 2004, at 18:49 Australia/Sydney, Mike Foskett wrote: Have you considered the documents appearance on a 160px wide PDA? How about a Braille reader? Surely you wouldn't deliver the layout CSS to either of these devices... semantically structured text and (for the PDA)

RE: [WSG] Absolute positioning vs floats

2004-08-25 Thread Mike Foskett
for elastic designs. mike 2k:)2 marqueeblink [EMAIL PROTECTED] http://www.webSemantics.co.uk /marquee/blink -Original Message- From: Nick Gleitzman [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: 25 August 2004 13:17 To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: [WSG] Absolute positioning vs floats

RE: [WSG] Absolute positioning vs floats

2004-08-25 Thread Mike Foskett
://www.webSemantics.co.uk /marquee/blink -Original Message- From: Kay Smoljak [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: 25 August 2004 11:03 To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: [WSG] Absolute positioning vs floats On Wed, 25 Aug 2004 09:49:52 +0100, Mike Foskett [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Personally, I go with floats