> The problem that I have with these solutions is that they require the
> syslog daemon to know if the time and timezone on the machine
> are valid.
> I can't think of any way of doing that.

Actually, I think this is the easy part. Its a trivial solution, but I
think it works. I think we can require that a syslog implementation - by
default - sets a "I am not sure about my time" flag. This is changed
only after the operator configures it to be differently.

> I'd would be perfectly happy
> with a recomendadtion that the hosts should hove the correct
> time/timezone information.  However, ultimatly it's the sys admin's
> problem if their machines have incorrect time/timezone.  And the sys
> admin which will suffer for it.
>
> This isn't meat to trivialize the issue, but I don't think that it's a
> problem which we should try to solve in the syslog protocol.  You can
> only do so much to protect people from them selves.

I think this time its worth doing it. I see a real-world issue here. I
see a fairly simple solution for most of the part. I am still missing a
solution for this in the message. But I begin to recommend that we
actually put this "reliable time info" flag in a one-byte header field.
Looks ugly, but solves an issue...

Rainer


Reply via email to