> I was with you right up until the end, when you wrote:
I guess I ran out of gas :-)
>> Is Electronic music dying? Of course not - but I'm worried that this
"trend"
>> (if one can call it that) leads down the same path to Jazz - pushed to the
>> side, kept out of the limelight, only supported by the (small) subculture.
>> Whereas I'd hoped it would be blossoming, to take its proper place in the
>> popular culture (certainly here in America) as This Generation's Music.
>
> The only problem is, you earlier wrote in the same post:
>
>> This year, almost all evidence of DJ culture and live Electronic music
>> has vanished ... once you get past the Big Names (Chems, Sasha & Digweed,
>> Groove Armada, Pete Tong, The Prodigy, Paul Oakenfold, Tiesto) there's
>> hardly any evidence of the adventurousness of the late '99 bill
>
> It seems that maybe I'm misunderstanding your argument, but doesn't the fact
> that there *are* "Big Names" (as you put it) indicate that Electronic music
> is decisively *not* dying? Granted none of the Big Names you cited mean
> anything to me, but isn't that often the way of it?
Good point. I guess what I was really trying to say there was, in the
case of, say, Coachella '99, there was a sense of Electronic music being
*pervasive* at the event - it was really an Electronic music festival that had
This Other Massive Stage With People From Other Realms To Help Pay The Bills,
if that helps any. But if you ignored That Other Massive Stage (which I did),
it was pretty much the Coachella Valley Electronic Music Festival. Whereas
this year's festival is more like the Coachella Valley Same Ol' Same Ol' Rock
And Some Hip-Hop Festival, with some Big Names to keep Those Electronica Kids
happy. In a way, almost like an inverted Audiotistic - they function in
the same sense with respect to the rest of the bill as all the Hip-Hop acts
do for Audiotistic.
This inverted sense of how things are now versus how things seemed to be
going a couple of years ago is what made me say what I did. Is that better?
> I personally don't see this year's DEMF lineup as indicative of anything
> besides the tastes of the panel that chose it, by the way.
True - that seems to be pretty evident.
I think what's interesting to consider, when thinking about Dan's and Carl's
comments about the scope of the DEMF, is this:
By turning the DEMF into more of a Festival of Electronic Music from Detroit
(and Detroit-influenced/friendly), does this run the risk of:
(1) Lowering the likely local crowd size ("Aw man, that DEMF lineup is whack.
I can see any of those dudes here, whenever I want.")
(2) Alienating some of the (non-hardcore) out-of-town potential audience,
for whom part of the attraction of the DEMF is to see not only Our
Favorite Detroit artists, but also those artists whom we never really
get a chance to see - certainly not too often on American soil - in
such an inviting surrounding framework? (I'm thinking the Chain Reaction
guys being at DEMF 1, Autechre at DEMF 2, Titonton's live set at DEMF 2,
Laurent Garnier's live band at DEMF 2, and so on ... )
Note that this is somewhat academic/existential on my part - you all know
my Technotourist ass is gonna be there no matter what :)
- Greg (who just flogged himself for the Hilburn-ism of "inviting
surrounding framework" ... kill me if I ever say "textures")
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]