Hi Geoff, Thanks for sending out the new revision. One question, one comment.
Question: could you explain the rationale for leaving out the fragmentation recovery item? Comment: "3. Produce "6LoWPAN Architecture" to describe the design and implementation of 6LoWPAN networks. This document will cover the concepts of "Mesh Under" and "Route Over", 802.15.4 design issues such as operation with sleeping nodes, network components (both battery- and line-powered), addressing, and IPv4/IPv6 network connections. As a spin-off from that document, "6LoWPAN Routing Requirements" will describe 6LoWPAN-specific requirements on routing protocols used in 6LoWPANs, addressing both the "route-over" and "mesh-under" approach. Both documents will be informational." I do not understand the rationale here: I think that we should first determine whether we both need a mesh-under *and* a route-over approach. You know my opinion: we have numerous examples in the past of such approaches that ALL failed for obvious technical reasons but this is my technical opinion. As far as 6lowpan is concerned, shouldn't we first have a discussion to get a consensus there ? *If* it turns out that both are needed, then add an introductory section in the architecture document pointing to the requirement document(s). Thus I would rather suggest not to list this as a WG item but to leave it out for the moment and continue to have the discussion until we have a consensus. Then at that point we could decide what to do. On the other hand, having a separate documents listing the 6LoWPAN specific routing requirements, owned by the 6lowpan WG and reviewed by ROLL would make a lot of sense. Thoughts ? Thanks. JP. On 6/13/08 3:59 PM, "Geoff Mulligan" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > With the input from the authors we've put the "Use Cases" back into the > text for the charter for the working group with a delivery date of Dec > 08. > > Attached is the NEW new charter text. > > geoff > > _______________________________________________ > 6lowpan mailing list > [email protected] > https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/6lowpan _______________________________________________ 6lowpan mailing list [email protected] https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/6lowpan
