>masochistic altruist who will go back and remove all the
line-break !s 
>from all the tune files created with abc2win over the last eight
years or so which 
>might annoy 

I guess it's quite easy, sitting confortable behind my computer
without knowing how to program, to find a "solution" for a
programming problem. Sorry if it's not easy to code, I don't know
at all about  this issue, but it seems it could be possible to
consider "only one ! between two | | = line break" while "going by
pair ! ! between two | | = !...! decoration". I doubt someone
would use | inside !...! notation. If so, one could only blame
oneself if it doesn't display correctly. And I doubt also someone
would use both convention in the same notation. We could consider
it's not "allowed" in the 2.0 standard to use both. What I'm
almost 100% sure is all the Abc2win abc files that cause this
problem don't use the !...! notation at all.

barline (optional : blablabla) only-one-! blablabla barline = line
break
barline !...! blablabla (optional : !...!) blablabla = !...!
decoration language

more clearly in abc format :

| abcd ! abcd | = line break (it's obvious one shouldn't use 2
line breaks in the same mesure)

| abcd !whatever! abcd = !...! decoration


>On the other hand, we do have to maintain some compatibility with

>abc2win's
>files, because they are priceless.  What we must avoid is adding 
>something
>to the language which prevents new programs which conform to the
newest
>standard from being capable of dealing with abc2win's files.

it may be also possible to make as default mode the !...! notation
and to put as option (in windows application) or flag (in dos
parser) the ! line break so people could choose what mode is
suitable for them. As far as I'm concerned I don't have any use of
the ! line break, I prefer to keep my tunes as compact as possible
when I print them or use P: parts instead to note different parts,
but I can undestand some ppl may like this feature. 
Again, 
abcd | abcd |
abcd | abcd |

is supposed to have a line break after the second mesure


___________________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!? -- Une adresse @yahoo.fr gratuite et en fran�ais !
Yahoo! Mail : http://fr.mail.yahoo.com
To subscribe/unsubscribe, point your browser to: http://www.tullochgorm.com/lists.html

Reply via email to